From: "Wallace Polsom" <wallace-AT-raggedclaws.com>
Subject: Re: BHA: Notes for a reading group
Date: Sun, 6 Aug 2000 14:37:39 -0600


Hi Ian,

Have you tried searching the Bhaskar.archive? The URL is

http://lists.village.virginia.edu/cgi-bin/spoons/archive1.pl?list=bhaskar.ar
chive

If you enter the name "Bourdieu" in the search box, and press "Search all
files in directory," you will get the following result:

=========
Search results for string "Bourdieu" in bhaskar.archive

bhaskar.0004
bhaskar.0006
bhaskar.0007

=========
Now click the first link, i.e., bhaskar.0004, and you will be presented with
a page that lists the "Contents of bhaskar.archive/bhaskar.0004, 2000."

Okay? Okay.

Now all you have to do is enter the word "Bourdieu" in the search box on
that page, press "Search all messages in file," and you will get a page that
looks something like this:

=========
Search results for string "Bourdieu" in bhaskar.archive/bhaskar.0004, 2000
14   Apr 7   Tobin Nellhaus       Re: BHA: Negelect of Bhaskar (Marx?) (63
lines)
      come up with is arguing that so-and-so (Bourdieu, Derrida, whoever) is
15   Apr 07  Karl Maton           Re: BHA: Negelect of Bhaskar (Marx?) (86
lines)
      > come up with is arguing that so-and-so (Bourdieu, Derrida, whoever)
is
      Elias or Bourdieu).  Also, it's more a general impression I've picked
up
17   Apr 08  Heikki Patomaki      BHA: On being CR, cosmopolitanism and a
conference advert (197 lines)
      >come up with is arguing that so-and-so (Bourdieu, Derrida, whoever)
is
19   Apr 09  ERIK WEISSENGRUBER   Re: BHA: Negelect of Bhaskar (Marx?) (89
lines)
      >come up with is arguing that so-and-so (Bourdieu, Derrida, whoever)
is
26   Apr 11  ERIK WEISSENGRUBER   BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy of
Science (141 lines)
      A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the work of
the
      Despite Bourdieu's avowed anti-ontological stance, he seems to be
close to
      So Bourdieu's innovations in reflexive sociology might be one tangent
for
      NOTE: Bourdieu does this amazing dissection of the
27   Apr 11  Colin Wight          BHA: RE: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy of
Science (202 lines)
      I absolutely agree with much of what you say and Bourdieu is very
similar to
      Bourdieu would see relations existing on the same ontological plane as
the
      of "depth" which is utilised by CR. After all, Bourdieu believes that
'there
      constraining their practices or their representations' (Bourdieu,  In
Other
      > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
28   Apr 11  Tobin Nellhaus       BHA: Re: RE: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy
of Science (55 lines)
      between Bourdieu and CR.  I don't have the citation at hand, but it's
in the
      But I too have doubts that for Bourdieu, relations exist on the same
      Bourdieu's argument for the existence of various types of capital
29   Apr 11  Roy Wilson           BHA: Bourdieu and CR           (193 lines)
          The proposed link between Bourdieu and CR might be strengthened by
the
      > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      > Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the work
of the
      > Despite Bourdieu's avowed anti-ontological stance, he seems to be
close to
      > So Bourdieu's innovations in reflexive sociology might be one
tangent for
32   Apr 11  Karl Maton           Re: BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy of
Science (91 lines)
      > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      I'm intrigued by this, as someone who uses both Bhaskar and Bourdieu.
I
      would describe Bourdieu as someone interested in epistemology, but not
      Without going into it in too much depth here, Bourdieu offers a
      > Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the work
of the
33   Apr 11  Karl Maton           Re: BHA: RE: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy
of Science (226 lines)
      > I absolutely agree with much of what you say and Bourdieu is very
similar to
      > Bourdieu would see relations existing on the same ontological plane
as the
      > of "depth" which is utilised by CR. After all, Bourdieu believes
that 'there
      > constraining their practices or their representations' (Bourdieu,
In Other
      > > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
34   Apr 11  Karl Maton           Re: BHA: Bourdieu and CR       (189 lines)
      >     The proposed link between Bourdieu and CR might be strengthened
by the
      > > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      > > Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the work
of the
      > > Despite Bourdieu's avowed anti-ontological stance, he seems to be
close to
      > > So Bourdieu's innovations in reflexive sociology might be one
tangent for
36   Apr 11  Karl Maton           Re: BHA: Bourdieu and CR       (202 lines)
      >     The proposed link between Bourdieu and CR might be strengthened
by the
      > > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      > > Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the work
of the
      > > Despite Bourdieu's avowed anti-ontological stance, he seems to be
close to
      > > So Bourdieu's innovations in reflexive sociology might be one
tangent for
38   Apr 12  Marshall Feldman     BHA: RE: Bourdieu and CR       (236 lines)
      > Subject: BHA: Bourdieu and CR
      >     The proposed link between Bourdieu and CR might be strengthened
by the
      > > A key part of Pierre Bourdieu's project seems to be informing the
      > > Bourdieu (at least in "The Craft of Sociology") discusses the
      > > Despite Bourdieu's avowed anti-ontological stance, he seems to
42           Par Engholm          Re: BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy of
Science (160 lines)
      finding some common ground between CR and the work of Pierre Bourdieu.
I am
      foundations of Bourdieu's work, and in this work I strive to formulate
some
      synthesis of Bourdieu's version of the historical epistemology and
      Bourdieu, he is often trapped in a French discourse in which the very
term
       Thus, Bourdieu often speaks of the need to 'escape from realism'
(which
43   Apr 11  Roy Wilson           BHA: Fararo - Bourdieu <-> Giddens -
Bhaskar (118 lines)
      social practices? We show how Bourdieu's concept of habitus and
45   Apr 11  Roy Wilson           Re: BHA: RE: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy
of Science (273 lines)
          Axel van den Berg suggests that Giddens and Bourdieu "solve" the
      Bourdieuy for being too deterministic. For van den Berg, this is "a
sure sign of
      > > I absolutely agree with much of what you say and Bourdieu is very
similar to
      > > Bourdieu would see relations existing on the same ontological
plane as the
      > > of "depth" which is utilised by CR. After all, Bourdieu believes
that 'there
46   Apr 12  Par Engholm          Re: BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar/Philosophy of
Science (167 lines)
      finding some common ground between CR and the work of Pierre Bourdieu.
I am
      foundations of Bourdieu's work, and in this work I strive to formulate
some
      synthesis of Bourdieu's version of the historical epistemology and
      Bourdieu, he is often trapped in a French discourse in which the very
term
       Thus, Bourdieu often speaks of the need to 'escape from realism'
(which
51   Apr 13  steven wainwright    BHA: Re: Bourdieu & CR         (131 lines)
      I too have found a symbiotic relationship between CR and Bourdieu.  As
      Bourdieu in realist social science".  Here's the abstract!  (For a
whole
      This paper argues for the salience of the work of Pierre Bourdieu -
social
      that are the great strength of Bourdieu's impressive corpus of social
      research.  Moreover, I suggest Bourdieu's work is best read as a
variant of
55   Apr 14  Colin Wight          RE: BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar (Marx?) (93
lines)
      For everyone interested in the relationship between Bhaskar and
Bourdieu
      Realist interpretations of Bourdieu's theories are given particular
56   Apr 14  Colin Wight          RE: BHA: Neglect of Bhaskar (Marx?) (139
lines)
      Bourdieu's generative structuralism
       AB:  An internal reconstruction and an immanent critique of
Bourdieu's
      reconstruct Bourdieu's theory by an analysis of the relational logic
that
      permeates his whole work. Tracing the debt Bourdieu's approach owes to
      Bourdieu's epistemological writings of the 1960s and 70s. It tries to
make

=========
Of course, each of the items above is hyperlinked to the full text of the
message as stored in the archive, so you can easily read the messages you
think might be useful.

Now simply repeat the steps above for bhaskar.0006 and bhaskar.0007, and
you're done.

Sure, it's not the most elegant system in the world. But it works!

Sincerely,
Wallace


----- Original Message -----
From: "Ian Verstegen" <iversteg-AT-astro.ocis.temple.edu>
To: <bhaskar-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu>
Sent: Friday, August 04, 2000 12:08 PM
Subject: Re: BHA: Notes for a reading group


>
> To the list,
>
> Can anyone direct me to, or has anyone saved, past posts on Pierre
> Bordieu?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Ian
>
> **********************************************************
> Ian Verstegen
> Department of Art History
> Temple University               fax: (215) 204-7837
> 8th Floor Ritter Hall Annex     fax: (215) 204-6951
> Philadelphia, PA 19122          http://astro.temple.edu/~iversteg
> **********************************************************
>
>
>
>
>      --- from list bhaskar-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---
>



     --- from list bhaskar-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---