Date: Tue, 30 Nov 2004 12:41:00 -0800 (PST) From: Patrick Crosby <pfcrosby-AT-yahoo.com> Subject: Re: [BOU:] Re:Re: Home of Bourdieu It's sad that we got off on this tangent, but I do understand both sides. Both make quite valid points. There are probably a great many universities in the US and elsewhere that could be persuaded to host this list, but not in a week's time. Committees, admistrators, and so forth in most cases need to get involved. A number of viable options have been proposed, and I for one cannot readily say which is the better. Whatever choice is ultimately made I think is going to be a bit of a gamble. Two or three people so far have expressed a preference for one. I personally would be fine with that. Anyone have any objections? If not, I move we go with that. If it doesn't work out, we can try Google (which sounds easier to set up than Yahoo for reason of the required individual registrations there. I gather Google doesn't require that). --- j laari <jlaari-AT-cc.jyu.fi> wrote: > Malgosia, > > I'm not sure anymore what we are disputing. It seems > things aren't > exactly the same in North America and in Europe. > Here universities > are state universities, i.e. publicly funded, acting > and serving on a > state budget base, doing things the uni laws > require. That applies > also on computing centres (uni cc's). I think > there's nothing > miraculous about setting up the facilities. Indeed, > it's as laborous > as any technical work. I knew few people who went to > the private side > because of the stress caused by the hassle of uni cc > environment. > However, once the facilities up and running - from > the viewpoint of > end-user like me - then they surely are there, as if > waiting someone > to use them. > > When I spoke of public duty of universities - not of > computing > centres - I had in mind your original question: > > "I am seriously asking. Do you have some ethical > precept that says > mailing lists should be run for free?" > > My answer was and is: yes, I have, if not ethical, > at least in a > certain sense normative idea of public institution > like university to > do its share of public services, provided that list > contents are of > any intellectual/cultural worth. I don't have a > slightest idea how > this sounds in a probably a lot more competitive > society like yours, > but up here this isn't exactly a renegade idea. > > (Actually, here in Finland the government maintains > that universities > have certain responsibilities in relation to > competitiveness of the > society on the global market etc. etc. Call it > totalitarian or > whatever - that's the name of the game today whether > we like it or > not. To exaggerate a little: ministry of education > sets new criteria > for unis faster than anyone can meet them. In short: > at least here > unis do have certain public duties for the benefit > of society. - > However, the idea of "duty" I share isn't exactly > politically correct > utilitarianism, like the dominating policy is, but a > value- > theoretical view: unis must accommodate themselves > to contemporary > culture in order to have serious cultural value > today. Part of that > is providing (material and intellectual) tools for > enhancing > reflective social discussion - and god knows there's > lot to do on > that front. In a way, it's in a budget of a unis > even to participate > in providing some of these tools.) > > We can continue about that tomorrow. Now I got to go > home. It's time > for the supper. > > Sincerely, Jukka L > > > You talk about this as if these things > miraculously and sponanteously > > sprung out of the fertile soil of the > institutional environment. > > Listservers, like any computer software, require > money and human labor > > to be set up and to run. They are not just > "there", "waiting". > > Somebody labored to set them up for a specific > purpose on a hardware > > that somebody paid for, for a specific purpose. > And these things > > consume resources. Somebody has to pay for those, > and somebody has to > > maintain them with their labor. (...) > > ********************************************************************** > Contributions: bourdieu-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu > Commands: majordomo-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu > Requests: > bourdieu-approval-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu > ********************************************************************** Contributions: bourdieu-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu Commands: majordomo-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu Requests: bourdieu-approval-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005