File spoon-archives/foucault.archive/foucault_1998/foucault.9811, message 25


From: kjrufo-AT-bellsouth.net
Date: Sat, 14 Nov 1998 09:52:55 -0500
Subject: Re: Pinochet and disappeared




Daniel F. Vukovich wrote:

> Justice, like Truth, is but a mobile army of metaphors.  Surely we all know
> this, and surely we can all agree that -- therefore -- politics should be
> kept separate from this concept-metaphor, at least politics in a social,
> institutional sense.  Dont we all realize how inherently dangerous, if not
> evil, it is to actually try to put into practice ideas or values like
> Justice?  Mixing politics and justice is a recipe for the Gulag, esp if you
> throw some Hegel into the mix.
>
> As Hayek and Foucault and of course Nietzche have definitively shown, there
> is no such thing as social justice.  To think that there is, let alone to
> desire to see Pinochet tortured unto death, is in the last analysis part of
> a primitive, herd or tribal mentality that we ought to leave out of
> eternally recurring history/time.
>
> Daniel Vukovich
> English; The Unit for Criticism
> University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

While I have mixed (and rather inconclusive) feelings about the Pinochet
discussion, I do take some exception to a general Nietzschean disregard for the
potential of social justice.  Not attempting to be overly argumentative (well,
yet, at least :P), but doesn't that sort of thinking open oneself to a rather
unimpressive nihilism?  Maybe I misunderstand the use of "social justice" as
terminology...  Is it your contention that a "moral" justice cannot exist or that
an "ethical" justice cannot be imposed without consequences?

Ken Rufo
Speech and Communication
University of Georgia


   

Driftline Main Page

 

Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005