From: "John Foster" <borealis-AT-mercuryspeed.com> Subject: Re: Judi diaboli iudicio advocatus Date: Sun, 12 Jan 2003 07:54:06 -0800 "Subject: Judi diaboli iudicio advocatus >In the trial of Jud, rarely have I seen such naked contempt for a fellow thinker amongst iso-politicians; and I do smell iso-politics here, whose odour is adhominism.< Quite the contrary, Peter. It has been all of us who have been put on trial by Jud. He is a one man 'attempted' judicial system on both Heidegger, philosophers on this list, Germanic peoples, and who ever else....His judgements are all similar: ad hominem and even derived from false information. It is actually quite insulting to be compared to the terrorists who kill people and being convicted of "transcendental" viewpoints. Even Judernuts claims that something 'transcends' over the 'wires' that 'link' his sensory 'receptors' to his 'brain'. All that we do collectively is explain where Jud is making his judgements fallaciously. Even that is a task which is worthless because it is practically impossible to comprehend his text other than as slanderous, insulting and superficial. I don't read many of the thousands of messages that Jud sends out. I read about one or two paragraphs each month, and that is enough time to waste on this incompetent trouble maker. Some times it is necessary to judge the judge. I guess Jud will be spending most of his time typing away, but I for "all" will not be reading much of it. >I for one, in favour of Jud, submit that he stands upon the violence of the positive thesis; other more urbane philosophers might succumb to the bark of worldliness where Jud holds a steady plow.< I missed the meaning of this paragraph. Are you saying that you are in favour of Jud? The rest I cannot understand very much. <clip> >Best, >Peter Danenberg Best what? Are you best Peter? Where is worst Peter? Best regards for this day, a brilliant one, chao john foster --- from list heidegger-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu --- --- from list heidegger-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005