Date: Tue, 28 Jul 1998 00:58:21 -0400 (EDT) From: malgosia askanas <ma-AT-panix.com> Subject: Re: Wynship's proposals I have actually worked on a number of anti-engineering projects. My first anti-engineering job was at Raytheon Data Systems, in the late 70s, where they wanted to build a computer just like the IBM Series 1 with an operating system just like Multics. None of the people working on the OS had the slightest idea what an OS was, but we read many papers and each group -- there was a scheduler group and a memory management group and a file-system group and a couple of others -- designed its piece using the latest research papers. The interpersonal dynamics were, for some reason, very passionate and the groups all hated each other, so they purposefully kept from each other the details of the interfaces. So we had all these specs and all these partly-written pieces and then they called in a very prestigious consulting firm whose job it was to prove that the system would run correctly and efficiently. And they proved it. Two months later, the project was cancelled. Then I worked on the world's most ambitious optimizing compiler. We built this unbelievably optimizing global optimizer which represented a materialization of the most advanced research available at the time. The project lasted 5 years and towards the end involved 50 people. The compiler produced excellent code but ran 40 times too slowly. The project was cancelled. Then I worked on some factory-of-the future projects (this was the time of the factory of the future). Then I worked on some parallelizing compilers for some state-of-the-art parallel computers. Then I worked on Ada compilers for the Brilliant Eyes racket and on rapid-prototyping systems for DARPA. None of these yielded anything that was ever used, although all of them yielded according to spec. These were most definitely engineering projects, and in many cases the engineering was quite excellent. They were intellectually challenging, rigorous and innovative. Their ultimate uselessness was both sensed beforehand and taken as a matter of course when it was confirmed. Some were government contracts, others were commercial and/or industrial. I think that there are thousands of people who make their living as anti-engineers. -m
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005