File spoon-archives/marxism-general.archive/marxism-general_1997/marxism-general.9706, message 58


From: "Karl Carlile" <joseph-AT-indigo.ie>
Date: Mon, 16 Jun 1997 21:47:12 +0000
Subject: M-G: Globalisation attachemnt


 * This message contains the file 'global~1.txt', which has been
 * uuencoded. If you are using Pegasus Mail, then you can use
 * the browser's eXtract function to lift the original contents
 * out to a file, otherwise you will have to extract the message
 * and uudecode it manually.

begin 660 global~1.txt
M1VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B`R#0H-"-AT-T*5&AE('!O;&ET:6-S(&%N9"!E8V]N;VUI
M8W,-AT-;V8-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;-AT-T*#0H-"D=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-:7,-AT-86X-AT-
M:61E;VQO9VEC86P-AT-=&5R;2X-AT-270-AT-96YC;VUP87-S97,-AT-=&AE(&9R96YE=&EC
M(&EN=&5R;F%T:6]N86P-AT-97AP86YS:6]N(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-+2!A;B!E>'!A
M;G-I;VX-AT-=VAI8V-AT--AT-:&%S(&AA9"!D979A<W1A=&EN9R!C;VYS97%U96YC97,-AT-
M9F]R('1H92`-AT-;6%J;W)I='D-AT-;V8-AT-:'5M86YI='DN(%1H92!D96)A=&4-AT-87)O
M=6YD(&ET+"!H;W=E=F5R+"!H87,-AT-=&5N9&5D('1O(&]B<V-U<F4-AT-<F%T:&5R
M('1H86X-AT-8VQA<FEF>2!O=7(-AT-=6YD97)S=&%N9&EN9R!O9B!T:&4-AT-9F]R8V5S
M(&%T('=O<FLN($EN(&AI<R!S96-O;F0-AT-87)T:6-L92!O;B!T:&ES('-U8FIE
M8W0-AT-1&%V:60-AT-66%F9F4-AT-;&]O:W,-AT-870-AT-=&AE('!O;&ET:6-S(&%N9"!E8V]N
M;VUI8W,-AT-;V8-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;C$N#0H-"D%M;VYG('1H;W-E('=H;W-E
M('!R:6UA<GD-AT-8V]N8V5R;B!I<R!F;W(-AT-82!M;W)E(&-O;7!E=&ET:79E(&%N
M9"!E9F9I8VEE;G1L>2!F=6YC=&EO;FEN9R!N871I;VYA;"!C87!I=&%L:7-T
M(&5C;VYO;7DL('1H97)E(&%R92!D:6%M971R:6-A;&QY(&]P<&]S:71E('!O
M<VET:6]N<R!C;VYC97)N:6YG('1H92!R96%L:71Y(&]F(&=L;V)A;&ES871I
M;VXN(%1H92!N96\M;&EB97)A;"!R:6=H="!S=')O;F=L>2!A<'!R;W9E<R!O
M9B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-;&EM:71E9"!E9F9E8W1I=F5N97-S
M(&]F(&YA=&EO;F%L(&=O=F5R;FUE;G0-AT-:6YT97)V96YT:6]N+B`G02!M;W)E
M(&=L;V)A;&ES960-AT-96-O;F]M>2!I<R!I;B!M86YY('=A>7,-AT-82!M;W)E(&5F
M9FEC:65N="!O;F4G(&9O<F-I;F<-AT-9V]V97)N;65N=',-AT-=&\-AT-8F4-AT-;6]R92!C
M87)E9G5L(&EN(&AA;F1L:6YG('1H96ER(&5C;VYO;6EE<R`H5&AE($5C;VYO
M;6ES="`R,R!$96-E;6)E<B`Q.3DU("T-AT--2!*86YU87)Y(#$Y.38I+B!4:&4-AT-
M<F5M;W9A;"!O9B!M87)K970-AT-8V]N<W1R86EN=',-AT-+2!F<F5E('1R861E(&%N
M9"!D97)E9W5L871E9"!L86)O=7(-AT-86YD(&-A<&ET86P-AT-;6%R:V5T<R`M(&ES
M('-E96X-AT-87,-AT-=&AE(&]N;'D-AT-=V%Y('1O(&EN8W)E87-E9"!G<F]W=&-AT-L(&)A
M;&%N8V5D('1R861E(&%N9"!L;W=E<B!U;F5M<&QO>6UE;G0N($%T('1H92!O
M=&AE<B!P;VQE+"!W:71H('1H92!O;&0-AT-<V]C:6%L(&1E;6]C<F%T:6,-AT-2V5Y
M;F5S:6%N('-T<F%T96=Y(&YO(&QO;F=E<B!V:6%B;&4L(&9O<FUE<B!S;V-I
M86P-AT-9&5M;V-R871S+"!C;VYC97)N960-AT-=&\-AT-<F5T86EN('-O;64-AT-<')O9W)E
M<W-I=F4-AT-<F]L92!F;W(-AT-82!R969O<FUI;F<-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES="!G;W9E<FYM
M96YT+"!H879E(&%R9W5E9"!T:&%T(&UU8V-AT--AT-=&%L:R!A8F]U="!G;&]B86QI
M<V%T:6]N(&ES(&5X86=G97)A=&5D+B`-AT-5&AE(&YO=&EO;B!T:&%T('1H97)E
M(&ES("=O;F4-AT-9VQO8F%L+"!B;W)D97)L97-S+"!S=&%T96QE<W,-AT-;6%R:V5T
M)R!I<R!A(&UY=&-AT-N("=4:&ES(&=L;V)A;"!E8V]N;VUY(&YE961S('-U<&5R
M:6YT96YD:6YG(&%N9"!P;VQI8VEN9RX-AT-1V]V97)N;65N=',-AT-8V%N(&%N9"!S
M:&]U;&0-AT-8V\M;W)D:6YA=&4-AT-=&AE:7(-AT-<&]L:6-I97,-AT-=&\-AT-;6%N86=E(&ET
M)R`H5VEL;"!(=71T;VX-AT-5&AE($=U87)D:6%N(#$W($IU;F4-AT-,3DY-2DN#0H-AT-
M(`T*5&AI<R!P;VQA<FES871I;VX-AT-:7,-AT-;6ER<F]R960-AT-;VX-AT-=&AE('-O8VEA
M;&ES="!L969T+B!/;B!T:&4-AT-;VYE('-I9&4L('=E(&%R92!T;VQD('1H870-AT-
M=&AE<F4-AT-:&%S(&)E96X-AT-86X-AT-97!O8VAA;"!S:&EF="!I;B!C87!I=&%L:7-M
M(&EN('=H:6-H(&YE=R!T96-H;F]L;V=Y(&AA<R!S=6)S=&%N=&EA;&QY("AI
M<G)E=F5R<VEB;'D_*2!I;F-R96%S960-AT-=&AE('!O=V5R(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-
M;W9E<B!L86)O=7(L(&9R86=M96YT:6YG(&%N9"!E=F5N(&1E<W1R;WEI;F<-AT-
M=V]R:VEN9R!C;&%S<R!O<F=A;FES871I;VYS+"!A;F0-AT-8W)E871I;F<-AT-9VQO
M8F%L(&UA<FME="!F;W)C97,-AT-8F5Y;VYD(&YA=&EO;F%L(&=O=F5R;FUE;G0-AT-
M8V]N=')O;"X-AT-3F]T('1O(')E8V]G;FES92!T:&5S92!D979E;&]P;65N=',-AT-
M)V9R965Z97,-AT-=7,-AT-:6X-AT-;6]D97,-AT-86YD(&9O<FUS(&]F('-T<G5G9VQE('=H
M:6-H(&%R92!E9F9E=&4-AT-86YD(&EN969F96-T=6%L)RA!(%-I=F%N86YD86XI
M+B!/;B!T:&4-AT-;W1H97(-AT-<VED92P-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B!I<R!S965N(&%S
M("`G86X-AT-:61E;VQO9VEC86P-AT-;7ES=&EF:6-A=&EO;B<-AT-=VAI8V-AT--AT-)W-E<G9E
M<R!A<R!A;B!E>&-U<V4-AT-(&9O<B!T:&4-AT-;6]S="!C;VUP;&5T92!D969E871I
M<VT-AT-86YD(&9O<B!T:&4-AT-86)A;F1O;FUE;G0-AT-;V8-AT-86YY(&MI;F0-AT-;V8-AT-86YT
M:2UC87!I=&%L:7-T('!R;VIE8W0N)R!!;F0-AT-=&AA="P-AT-=VAI;&4-AT-;F]T(&1E
M;GEI;F<-AT-=&AE(&EM<&%C="!O9B!N97<-AT-=&5C:&YO;&]G:65S(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-
M9&5S=')U8W1I=F4-AT-969F96-T<R!O9B!D97)E9W5L871I;VXL(&UA<W,-AT-=6YE
M;7!L;WEM96YT(&%N9"!G<F]W:6YG('!O=F5R='DL('=E(&YE960-AT-=&\-AT-;&]O
M:R!E;'-E=VAE<F4-AT-9F]R(&%N(&5X<&QA;F%T:6]N(&]F('1H92!L;VYG+71E
M<FT-AT-<W1R=6-T=7)A;"!C<FES:7,-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES;2!T:&%N(&EN('-I
M;7!L:7-T:6,-AT-9F]R;75L87,-AT-86)O=70-AT-)V=L;V)A;&ES871I;VXG*$5L;&5N
M($UE:6MS:6YS(%=O;V0I+C(-AT-#0H-"D=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-86YD(&YA=&EO
M;F%L(&=O=F5R;FUE;G1S#0H-"-AT-T*5&AE('!O;&EC:65S(&]F(&YA=&EO;F%L
M(&=O=F5R;FUE;G1S(&EN(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S(&%R92!M86EN
M;'D-AT-9&5T97)M:6YE9"!B>2!T=V\-AT-:6UP;W)T86YT(&1Y;F%M:6-S.B!T:&4-AT-
M9FER<W0-AT-:7,-AT-=&AE('-T871E(&]F('1H92!N871I;VYA;"!P<F]C97-S(&]F
M(&-A<&ET86P-AT-86-C=6UU;&%T:6]N(&%N9"!I=',-AT-<F5L871I=F4-AT-:6YT97)N
M871I;VYA;"!S=')E;F=T:#L-AT-=&AE('-E8V]N9"!I<R!T:&4-AT-8F%L86YC92!O
M9B!C;&%S<R!F;W)C97,-AT-8F]T:"!N871I;VYA;&QY(&%N9"!I;G1E<FYA=&EO
M;F%L;'DN($ET(&ES(&]F(&QI='1L92!S=7)P<FES92!T:&%T('1H92!C;VYC
M97!T(&]F("=G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N)R!I<R!B96EN9R!D:7-C=7-S960[("-AT-Q
M*2!D=7)I;F<-AT-82!P97)I;V0-AT-;V8-AT-<W1A9VYA=&EN9R!N871I;VYA;"!C87!I
M=&%L(&%C8W5M=6QA=&EO;B!A<R!E>&-E<W,-AT-8V%P:71A;"!I<R!A9V=R97-S
M:79E;'D-AT-97AP;W)T960-AT-;W(-AT-9&5P;&]Y960-AT-<W!E8W5L871I=F5L>2!O;B!T
M:&4-AT-<W1O8VL-AT-;6%R:V5T<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-=V]R;&0-AT-=&\-AT-<W1A=F4-AT-;V9F(&$-AT-
M<')O9FET<R!C;VQL87!S92!A;F0-AT-*#(I(&9O;&QO=VEN9R!A(&1R86UA=&EC
M('-H:69T(&EN('1H92!B86QA;F-E(&]F(&-L87-S(&9O<F-E<R!N871I;VYA
M;&QY(&%N9"!I;G1E<FYA=&EO;F%L;'D-AT-:6X-AT-9F%V;W5R(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-
M869T97(-AT-=&AE('-U8V-E<W-F=6P-AT-8V]U;G1E<F%T=&%C:R!A9V%I;G-T(&QA
M8F]U<B!I;B!T:&4-AT-,3DX,',L(&%N(&%T=&%C:R!W:&EC:"!H:6=H;&EG:'1E
M9"!T:&4-AT-=V5A:VYE<W,-AT-;V8-AT-=V]R:VEN9R!C;&%S<R!A;F0-AT-<V]C:6%L:7-T
M(&9O<F-E<R!W;W)L9"T-AT-=VED92X-AT-(`T*#0I4;VYY($)L86ER+"!T:&4-AT-;F5W
M($)R:71I<V-AT--AT-3&%B;W5R(%!R:6UE($UI;FES=&5R+"`-AT-=V%S('-I;7!L>2`-AT-
M9VEV:6YG(&5X<')E<W-I;VX-AT-=&\-AT-=&AE<V4-AT-<F5A;&ET:65S('=H96X-AT-:&4-AT-
M=&]L9"!A(&-O;F9E<F5N8V4-AT-;V8-AT-4G5P97)T($UU<F1O8V-AT-G<R!.97=S($-O
M<G!O<F%T:6]N(&EN(#$Y.34Z#0H-"B=7:&%T("!I<R!C86QL960-AT-9VQO8F%L
M:7-A=&EO;B!I<R!C:&%N9VEN9R!T:&4-AT-;F%T=7)E(&]F('1H92!N871I;VX-AT-
M<W1A=&4-AT-87,-AT-<&]W97(-AT-8F5C;VUE<R!M;W)E(&1I9F9U<V4-AT-86YD(&)O<F1E
M<G,-AT-;6]R92!P;W)O=7,N(%1E8VAN;VQO9VEC86P-AT-8VAA;F=E(&ES(')E9'5C
M:6YG('1H92!P;W=E<B!A;F0-AT-8V%P86-I='D-AT-;V8-AT-9V]V97)N;65N="!T;R!C
M;VYT<F]L(&ET<R!D;VUE<W1I8R!E8V]N;VUY(&9R964-AT-9G)O;2!E>'1E<FYA
M;"!I;F9L=65N8V4G("A&:6YA;F-I86P-AT-5&EM97,-AT-(#(P($UA<F-H(#$Y.38I
M+-AT-T*#0I);B!E9F9E8W0-AT-:&4-AT-:7,-AT-<F5A<W-U<FEN9R!T:&4-AT-9&]M:6YA;G0-AT-
M<V5C=&EO;G,-AT-;V8-AT-0G)I=&ES:"!C87!I=&%L('=I=&-AT--AT-82!V97)Y('-T<F]N
M9R!I;G1E<FYA=&EO;F%L('!R97-E;F-E+"!T:&%T+"!W:71H(&1O;65S=&EC
M(&-A<&ET86P-AT-86-C=6UU;&%T:6]N('-T86=N871I;F<L(&AE('=I;&P-AT-;F]T
M('-T86YD("!I;B!T:&4-AT-=V%Y(&]F($)R:71I<V-AT--AT-8V%P:71A;"!E=F5N(&EF
M('1H:7,-AT-:7,-AT-870-AT-=&AE(&5X<&5N<V4-AT-;V8-AT-(&UI;&QI;VYS(&]F('!E;W!L
M92!I;B!"<FET86EN(&-O;F9R;VYT:6YG(&1R87-T:6,-AT-8W5T<R!I;B!S=&%T
M92!W96QF87)E(&%N9"!G<F]W:6YG("!I;7!O=F5R:7-H;65N="X-AT-($]N(&YO
M(&]T:&5R(&)A<VES+"!G:79E;B!T:&4-AT-8F%L86YC92!O9B!C;&%S<R!F;W)C
M97,L(&-O=6QD(&AE(&QE860-AT-82!C87!I=&%L:7-T(&=O=F5R;FUE;G0-AT-:6X-AT-
M<')E<V5N="!D87D-AT-0G)I=&%I;BX-"-AT-T*5&AE(&YE;RUL:6)E<F%L($9I;F%N
M8VEA;"!4:6UE<R!J;W5R;F%L:7-T($UA<G1I;B!7;VQF(')E86-H97,-AT-<VEM
M:6QA<B!C;VYC;'5S:6]N<R!A8F]U="!T:&4-AT-;&EM:71E9"!R;VQE(&]F(&YA
M=&EO;F%L(&=O=F5R;FUE;G1S(&EN(&$-AT-9VQO8F%L(&5C;VYO;7D-AT-8G5T('!L
M87ES(&1O=VX-AT-=&AE(&EM<&%C="!O9B`G9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B<Z#0H-"B=7
M:&5N('!E;W!L92!W<FET92!O9F8-AT-=&AE(&5N9"!O9B!N871I;VYA;"!E8V]N
M;VUI8R!S;W9E<F5I9VYT>2P-AT-:70-AT-:7,-AT-86X-AT-:&ES=&]R:6-A;&QY(&)R:65F
M(&5R82!T:&%T('1H97D-AT-;&%M96YT+B`-AT-270-AT-96YD960-AT-;F]T('-O(&UU8V-AT--AT-
M=6YD97(-AT-=&AE(&%S<V%U;'0-AT-;V8-AT-86X-AT-97AT97)N86P-AT-9F]R8V4L('1H92!G
M;&]B86P-AT-;6%R:V5T+"!B=70-AT-;V8-AT-86X-AT-:6YT97)N86P-AT-;VYE+"!P97)C96EV
M960-AT-9F%I;'5R92X-AT-1V]V97)N;65N=',-AT-=V5R92!B860-AT-870-AT-;75C:"!O9B!W
M:&%T('1H97D-AT-=V5R92!D;VEN9RXN+D=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-<F5I;F9O<F-E
M9"!T:&4-AT-;&EM:71S(&%L<F5A9'D-AT-:6UP;W-E9"!B>2!D;VUE<W1I8R!C;VYS
M=')A:6YT<R<-AT-*$9I;F%N8VEA;"!4:6UE<R`Q."!397!T96UB97(-AT-,3DY-2DN
M#0H-"E=O;&8G<R!A='1A8VL-AT-;VX-AT-=&AE(&5C;VYO;6EC(')O;&4-AT-;V8-AT-9V]V
M97)N;65N="!A9V%I;B!G:79E<R!I9&5O;&]G:6-A;"!E>'!R97-S:6]N('1O
M('1H92!C:&%N9V5D(&YE961S(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-:6X-AT-=&]D87DG<R!C:7)C
M=6US=&%N8V5S+B!(:7,-AT-97AP;&%N871I;VX-AT-9&EF9F5R<R!F<F]M($)L86ER
M("T-AT-=&AE>2!S<&5A:R!T;R!A(&1I9F9E<F5N="!C;VYS=&ET=65N8WD-AT-+2!B
M=70-AT-:6YE=FET86)L>2!T:&5Y(')E86-H('1H92!S86UE(&-L87-S('-T86YD
M<&]I;G0N("`-"-AT-T*5&AE("`G:&ES=&]R:6-A;&QY(&)R:65F(&5R82<-AT-(&]F
M('-T871E(&EN=&5R=F5N=&EO;B!I;B!T:&4-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES="!E8V]N;VUY
M(&%F=&5R(#$Y-#4-AT-=V%S('1H92!P<F]D=6-T(&]F('5N:7%U92!H:7-T;W)I
M8V%L(&-I<F-U;7-T86YC97,N($9I<G-T+"!I;G1E<BUI;7!E<FEA;&ES="!R
M:79A;')Y(&)E='é6X-AT-=&AE(&UA:F]R(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-<&]W97)S('-I
M;F-E('1H92!B96=I;FYI;F<-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&-E;G1U<GD-AT-:&%D(&5N9&5D+"!T
M96UP;W)A<FEL>2P-AT-=VET:"!T:&4-AT-9&]M:6YA;F-E(&]F(%53(&EM<&5R:6%L
M:7-M(&]V97(-AT-=&AE(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-=V]R;&0-AT-96-O;F]M>2X-AT-5&AI<R!A
M;&QO=V5D('1H92!54R!E8V]N;VUY+"!F86-I;F<-AT-;&EM:71E9"!C;VUP971I
M=&EO;BP-AT-=&\-AT-9&5V96QO<"!A="!T:&4-AT-97AP96YS92!O9B!O=&AE<B!N871I
M;VYA;"!C87!I=&%L<RX-AT-5&AR;W5G:"!-87)S:&%L;"!!:60-AT-86YD(&5X<&]R
M="!O9B!C87!I=&%L+"!T:&4-AT-55,-AT-;&%I9"!T:&4-AT-8F%S:7,-AT-9F]R(&EN8W)E
M87-I;F<-AT-8V]N=')O;"!O9B!W;W)L9"!M87)K971S(&9O<B!54R!C87!I=&%L
M(&%N9"!A(&9A<W1E<B!R871E(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-86-C=6UU;&%T:6]N(&%T
M(&AI9V-AT--AT-<F%T97,-AT-;V8-AT-<')O9FET+B!"<FET86EN+"!W:71H(&ET<R!A8V-E
M<W,-AT-=&\-AT-=&AE(&UA<FME=',-AT-86YD(')E<V]U<F-E<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-0G)I=&ES
M:"!%;7!I<F4-AT-86YD('=I=&-AT--AT-;&ET=&QE(&-O;7!E=&ET:6]N(&9R;VT-AT-:71S
M($5U<F]P96%N(')I=F%L<RP-AT-9F]L;&]W960-AT-:6X-AT-:71S('=A:V4N(%-E8V]N
M9"P-AT-82`-AT-8VAA;F=E("!I;B!T:&4-AT-8F%L86YC92!O9B!C;&%S<R!F;W)C97,-AT-
M:6X-AT-9F%V;W5R(&]F('1H92!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S(&AA9"!O8V-U<G)E9"!I
M;G1E<FYA=&EO;F%L;'D-AT-869T97(-AT-=&AE(&1E=F%S=&%T:6]N(&]F(&1E<')E
M<W-I;VXL(&9A<V-I<VT-AT-86YD('1W;R!W;W)L9"!W87)S+"!A(&-H86YG92!R
M96EN9F]R8V5D(&)Y('1H92!S=&%N9&EN9R!O9B!T:&4-AT-4V]V:65T(%5N:6]N
M(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-<W!R96%D(&]F('-O8VEA;&ES="!R979O;'5T:6]N<R!A;F0-AT-
M:6YD97!E;F1E;F-E(&UO=F5M96YT<R!A9G1E<B!T:&4-AT-=V%R+-AT-T*#0I4:&4-AT-
M<F5S=&]R871I;VX-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;"!A8V-U;75L871I;VX-AT-869T97(-AT-=&AE
M('=A<B!W87,-AT-86-H:65V960L('1H97)E9F]R92P-AT-870-AT-82!P;VQI=&EC86P-AT-
M8V]S="!T;R!C87!I=&%L+B!4:&4-AT-8F%L86YC92!O9B!C;&%S<R!F;W)C97,-AT-
M;F5C97-S:71A=&5D('1H:7,N($)U="!I="!W87,-AT-82!C;W-T('1H870L(&EN
M:71I86QL>2!I;B!T:&4-AT-=FEC=&]R:6]U<R!N871I;VYS(&%N9"P-AT-;&%T97(L
M(&EN('1H92!R96)U:6QT($5U<F]P96%N(&5C;VYO;6EE<RP-AT-8V%P:71A;"!C
M;W5L9"!A9F9O<F0N(%-T871E(&EN=&5R=F5N=&EO;B!I;B!T:&4-AT-8V%P:71A
M;&ES="!E8V]N;VUY+"`-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-=V5L9F%R92!A;F0-AT-;6EL:71A<GD-AT-<W!E
M;F1I;F<L(&EN('1H97-E('5N:7%U92!C:7)C=6US=&%N8V5S+"`-AT-=6YD97)P
M:6YN960-AT-=&AE(&UO<W0-AT-<F%P:60-AT-86-C=6UU;&%T:6]N(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-
M979E<BX-AT-($)U="!T:&4-AT-9G5N9&%M96YT86P-AT-8V]N=')A9&EC=&EO;G,-AT-=VET
M:&EN('1H92!C87!I=&%L(&%C8W5M=6QA=&EO;B!P<F]C97-S(')E;6%I;F5D
M+B!7:&5N('1H92!R871E(&]F('!R;V9I="!B96=A;B!T;R!F86QL(&%N9"!I
M;G1E<BUI;7!E<FEA;&ES="!R:79A;')I97,-AT-<F4M96UE<Fé"!A="!B96=I
M;FYI;F<-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(#$Y-S!S+"!C87!I=&%L(&%C8W5M=6QA=&EO;B!B96=A
M;B!T;R!S=&%G;F%T92!I;B!M;W-T(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S+B!4
M:&4-AT-<FES:6YG(&-O;G-U;7!T:6]N(&EN<W1I='5T:6]N86QI<V5D(&EN('-T
M871E('=E;&9A<F4-AT-8F5C86UE(&$-AT-8F%R<FEE<B!T;R!T:&4-AT-9G5R=&AE<B!A
M8V-U;75L871I;VX-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;"!A<R!H:6=H(&EN9FQA=&EO;B!A8V-O
M;7!A;FEE9"!S=&%G;F%T:6]N(&EN('1H92!M86IO<B!C87!I=&%L:7-T(&YA
M=&EO;G,N(%-T871E('-P96YD:6YG(&%N9"!S=&%T92!W96QF87)E(&AA9"!T
M;R!B92!C=70-AT-8F%C:RX-AT-26X-AT-0G)I=&%I;B!T:&4-AT-9FER<W0-AT-<W1E<',-AT-=V5R
M92!T86ME;B!B>2!A($QA8F]U<B!G;W9E<FYM96YT(&$-AT-9F5W('EE87)S(&)E
M9F]R92!4:&%T8VAE<B!C86UE(&EN=&\-AT-<&]W97(N($-A<&ET86P-AT-=V5N="!O
M;B!T:&4-AT-;V9F96YS:79E(&%N9"!S=6-C965D960-AT-:6X-AT-8VAA;F=I;F<-AT-=&AE
M(&)A;&%N8V4-AT-;V8-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-9F]R8V5S(&YA=&EO;F%L;'D-AT-86YD(&EN=&5R
M;F%T:6]N86QL>2!B=70-AT-=&AE('!R;V)L96US('=I=&AI;B!T:&4-AT-8V%P:71A
M;"!A8V-U;75L871I;VX-AT-<')O8V5S<R!R96UA:6YE9"X-AT-4W1A=&4-AT-:6YT97)V
M96YT:6]N("!W87,-AT-;F5I=&AE<B!R97-P;VYS:6)L92!F;W(-AT-=&AE('!O<W0-AT-
M=V%R(&)O;VT-AT-;F]R('1H92!C875S92!O9B!T:&4-AT-;&%T97(-AT-<W1A9VYA=&EO
M;BX-AT-270-AT-=V%S('1H92!P87)T:6-U;&%R(&-I<F-U;7-T86YC97,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE
M(&-A<&ET86P-AT-86-C=6UU;&%T:6]N('!R;V-E<W,-AT-;F%T:6]N86QL>2!A;F0-AT-
M:6YT97)N871I;VYA;&QY('=H:6-H('5N9&5R;&%Y(&)O=&-AT-N("!+97EN97-I
M86YI<VT-AT-86YD(&YE;RUL:6)E<F%L:7-M(&%R92!N;R!M;W)E('1H86X-AT-:61E
M;VQO9VEC86P-AT-<F5F;&5C=&EO;G,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&-H86YG:6YG("!R97%U:7)E
M;65N=',-AT-(&]F(&-A<&ET86P-AT-:6X-AT-=&AE('1W;R!P97)I;V1S+-AT-T*#0I4:&4-AT-
M9W)O=VEN9R!S=&%G;F%T:6]N(&EN('1H92!C87!I=&%L(&%C8W5M=6QA=&EO
M;B!P<F]C97-S(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-<F4M96UE<F=E;F-E(&]F(&EN=&5R+6EM<&5R
M:6%L:7-T(')I=F%L<FEE<R!W97)E('1H92!R97-U;'0-AT-;V8-AT-86X-AT-;W9E<F%C
M8W5M=6QA=&EO;B!O9B!C87!I=&%L("T-AT-(&EN<W5F9FEC:65N="!S=7)P;'5S
M('9A;'5E('1O('-E8W5R92!B;W1H('1H92!N;W)M86P-AT-<')O9FET86)L92!E
M>'!A;G-I;VX-AT-;V8-AT-<')O9'5C=&EV92!C87!I=&%L(&%N9"!T;R!F:6YA;F-E
M('1H92!G<F]W:6YG("!S=&%T92!S96-T;W(-AT-=&]G971H97(-AT-=VET:"!A(')A
M<&ED;'D-AT-97AP86YD:6YG('5N<')O9'5C=&EV92!P<FEV871E('-E8W1O<BX-AT-
M5&AE(&AU9V4-AT-:6YC<F5A<V4-AT-:6X-AT-=&AE(&5X<&]R="!O9B!C87!I=&%L+"!T
M:&4-AT-9W)O=VEN9R!M;VYO<&]L:7-A=&EO;B!O9B!C87!I=&%L('1H<F]U9V-AT--AT-
M;65R9V5R<RP-AT-86-Q=6ES:71I;VYS(&%N9"!P<FEV871I<V%T:6]N<RP-AT-=&AE
M('5N<')E8V5D96YT960-AT-875T;VYO;7D-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&9I;F%N8VEA;"!S>7-T
M96T-AT-9G)O;2!R96%L('!R;V1U8W1I;VX-AT-86QO;F=S:61E('1H92!C=71S(&EN
M('-T871E('=E;&9A<F4L(&1O=VYS:7II;F<-AT-86YD(&]U='-O=7)C:6YG+"!M
M87-S('5N96UP;&]Y;65N="!A;F0-AT-<F%P:61L>2!G<F]W:6YG(&EN97%U86QI
M='DL(&EN('-H;W)T+"!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N+"!W87,-AT-8V%P:71A;"=S(')E
M<W!O;G-E+B`-"-AT-T*1VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;BP-AT-=&AE<F5F;W)E(&]N;'D-AT-<F5I
M;F9O<F-E<R!T:&4-AT-;&EM:71S(&EM<&]S960-AT-8GD-AT-9&]M97-T:6,-AT-8V]N<W1R
M86EN=',-AT-;VX-AT-;F%T:6]N86P-AT-9V]V97)N;65N="!I;G1E<G9E;G1I;VX-AT-8F5C
M875S92!B;W1H(')E<W5L="!F<F]M(&$-AT-<W1A9VYA=&EN9R!C87!I=&%L(&%C
M8W5M=6QA=&EO;BX-AT-5&AI<R!I<R!T:&4-AT-8V]N=&5X="!I;B!W:&EC:"!W92!C
M86X-AT-97AA;6EN92!T:&4-AT-9&EF9F5R:6YG(&-L87-S('!O<VET:6]N<R!O;B!G
M;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N+-AT-T*#0H-"D=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-86YD(&-L87-S(&EN
M=&5R97-T#0H-"DUA<G1I;B!7;VQF('%U:71E(&)R87IE;FQY(')E<')E<V5N
M=',-AT-=&AE(&1O;6EN86YT(')U;&EN9R!C;&%S<R!I;G1E<F5S=',N($%S(&$-AT-
M<W!O:V5S<&5R<V]N(&9O<B!L87)G92!C87!I=&%L+"!H92!I<R!A;B!U;F%S
M:&%M960-AT-87!O;&]G:7-T(&9O<B!N96\M;&EB97)A;&ES;2X-AT-26X-AT-82!R96-E
M;G0-AT-9VQO=VEN9R!T<FEB=71E('1O(&=L;V)A;&ES871I;VXL("!D:7-M:7-S
M:6YG(&%L;"!E=FED96YC92!T;R!T:&4-AT-8V]N=')A<GDL(&AE(&UA:6YT86EN
M<R!I="!H87,-AT-8F5E;B!A(&9O<F-E(&9O<B!P<F]S<&5R:71Y(&EN(&UU8V-AT--AT-
M;V8-AT-=&AE('=O<FQD+B`G1VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B!I<R!T:&4-AT-9W)E870-AT-96-O
M;F]M:6,-AT-979E;G0-AT-;V8-AT-;W5R(&5R82X-AT-270-AT-9&5F:6YE<R!W:&%T(&=O=F5R
M;FUE;G1S(&-A;B`M(&%N9"!S:&]U;&0-AT-9&]?5&5C:&YO;&]G>2!M86ME<R!G
M;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N(&9E87-I8FQE+B!,:6)E<F%L:7-A=&EO;B!I<R!R97-P
M;VYS:6)L92!F;W(-AT-:70-AT-:&%P<&5N:6YG+B<-AT-($AE(&-E;&5B<F%T97,-AT-:71S
M('-U8V-E<W,N($9R;VT-AT-,3DW,"!T;R`Q.3DW('1H92!N=6UB97(-AT-;V8-AT-8V]U
M;G1R:65S(')E;6]V:6YG(&5X8VAA;F=E(&-O;G1R;VQS(&]N(&=O;V1S(&%N
M9"!S97)V:6-E<R!I;F-R96%S960-AT-9G)O;2`S-2!T;R`Q,S<N($$-AT->65A<B!A
M9V\L(&UO<F4-AT-8V]N<W1R86EN960L("!I;B!A;B!A<G1I8VQE("=4:&4-AT-9VQO
M8F%L(&5C;VYO;7D-AT-;7ET:"<-AT-*$9I;F%N8VEA;"!4:6UE<R`Q,R!&96)R=6%R
M>2`Q.3DV*3,L(&AE(&%R9W5E9"!T:&%T(&UU8V-AT--AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('1A;&L-AT-86)O
M=70-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B!W87,-AT-97AA9V=E<F%T960-AT-86YD(&=O=F5R;FUE
M;G1S(&]N('1H96ER(&]W;B!O<B!T;V=E=&AE<B!C;W5L9"!D;R!A(&=R96%T
M(&1E86PN(%1O9&%Y(&AE(&AA<R!N;R!S=6-H(')E<V5R=F%T:6]N<RX-AT-26X-AT-
M:&ES(&QA=&5S="!A<G1I8VQE("=';&]B86P-AT-;W!P;W)T=6YI=&EE<R<-AT-:&4-AT-
M=&5L;',-AT-=7,-AT-=&AA="!G;W9E<FYM96YT<R!H879E(&QE87)N960-AT-=&AE(&QE
M<W-O;G,-AT-;V8-AT-97AP97)I96YC92!A;F0-AT-:&%V92!C:&]S96X-AT-;W(-AT-8F5E;B!F
M;W)C960-AT-=&\-AT-;W!E;B!T:&5I<B!E8V]N;VUI97,N(%)U;FYI;F<-AT-=VET:"!T
M:&4-AT-=&ED92P-AT-:&4-AT-;F]W(&%R9W5E<R!T:&%T+"!O;B!B86QA;F-E+"!G;&]B
M86QI<V%T:6]N(&AA<R!G;VYE(&9U<G1H97(-AT-=&AA;B!E=F5R(&)E9F]R92`H
M1FEN86YC:6%L(%1I;65S(#8-AT-36%Y(#$Y.3<I+-AT-T*#0I.97<-AT-3&%B;W5R('-T
M86YD<R!F;W(-AT-=&AE('-A;64-AT-<G5L:6YG(&-L87-S(&EN=&5R97-T<RX-AT-26X-AT-
M=&AE(')U;B!U<"!T;R!T:&4-AT-1V5N97)A;"!%;&5C=&EO;B!";&%I<B!W87,-AT-
M9F]R979E<B!S=')E<W-I;F<-AT-:&]W($QA8F]U<B!W;W5L9"!A8V-O;6UO9&%T
M92!M=6QT:6YA=&EO;F%L(&)U<VEN97-S+B!);6UE9&EA=&5L>2!A9G1E<B!T
M:&4-AT-96QE8W1I;VX-AT-:&4-AT-87!P;VEN=&5D(%-I<B!$879I9"!3:6UO;BP-AT-8VAA
M:7)M86X-AT-;V8-AT-0G)I=&ES:"!0971R;VQE=6TL(&%S(&$-AT-36EN:7-T97(-AT-;V8-AT-
M5')A9&4-AT-86YD($5U<F]P96%N($-O;7!E=&ET:79E;F5S<RX-AT-0E`-AT-:7,-AT-86-C
M=7-E9"!O9B!C;VQL86)O<F%T:6YG('=I=&-AT--AT-;6EL:71A<GD-AT-9&5A=&-AT--AT-<W%U
M861S(&EN($-O;'5M8FEA+B!3:6UO;B!W:6QL(&)E(&UA9&4-AT-82!L:69E('!E
M97(N($%L;6]S="!T:&4-AT-9FER<W0-AT-86-T(&]F('1H92!N97<-AT-9V]V97)N;65N
M="!W87,-AT-=&\-AT-:&%N9"!O=F5R(&-O;G1R;VP-AT-;V8-AT-:6YT97)E<W0-AT-<F%T92!P
M;VQI8WD-AT-=&\-AT-=&AA="!B87-T:6]N(&]F(&YE;RUL:6)E<F%L:7-M+"!T:&4-AT-
M0F%N:R!O9B!%;F=L86YD+B!.979E<G1H96QE<W,-AT-0FQA:7(-AT-8V%N;F]T+"!A
M<R!7;VQF(&ES(&%B;&4-AT-=&\-AT-9&\L(&-O;F9L871E('1H92`G8V%N)R!A;F0-AT-
M)W-H;W5L9"<-AT-;V8-AT-9V]V97)N;65N="!P;VQI8WD-AT-:6X-AT-<F5L871I;VX-AT-=&\-AT-
M82!G;&]B86P-AT-96-O;F]M>2X-AT-1F]R($)L86ER(&ES(')E;&EA;G0-AT-=&\-AT-<V]M
M92!D96=R964-AT-;VX-AT-=&AE(&UI9&1L92!C;&%S<R!C;VYS=&ET=65N8WD-AT-=VAI
M8V-AT--AT-96QE8W1E9"!H:6T-AT-=&\-AT-<&]W97(N($AE('=I;&P-AT-:&%V92!T;R!R96%S
M<W5R92!T:&4-AT-;6ED9&QE(&-L87-S97,L(&%S(')E86P-AT-96-O;F]M:6,-AT-9&5V
M96QO<&UE;G1S('1H<F5A=&5N('1H96ER('-E8W5R:71Y+"!T:&%T(&AE('=I
M;&P-AT-9&\-AT-=VAA="!H92!C86X-AT-=VET:&EN('1H92!C;VYS=')A:6YT<R!I;7!O
M<V5D(&)Y('1H92!G;&]B86P-AT-96-O;F]M>2`H)V5X=&5R;F%L(&EN9FQU96YC
M92<I+B!(92!I<R!A8V-E<'1A8FQE('1O('1H92!R=6QI;F<-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-8F5C
M875S92P-AT-=6YL:6ME('1H92!D:7-C<F5D:71E9"!A;F0-AT-9&EV:61E9"!4;W)I
M97,L($QA8F]U<B!I<R!I;B!A(&)E='1E<B!P;W-I=&EO;BP-AT-87,-AT-96-O;F]M
M:6,-AT-8V]N9&ET:6]N<R!D971E<FEO<F%T92P-AT-=&\-AT-<')E=F5N="!A;B!A;&QI
M86YC92!A9V%I;G-T(&-A<&ET86QI<VT-AT-9&5V96QO<&EN9R!B971W965N('1H
M92!P;V]R('=O<FMI;F<-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-86YD('-E8W1I;VYS(&]F('1H92!M:61D
M;&4-AT-8VQA<W-E<R!T:')E871E;F5D('=I=&-AT--AT-<')O;&5T87)I86YI<V%T:6]N
M+-AT-T*#0H-"DAU='1O;BP-AT-9V5N97)A;&QY(')E9V%R9&5D(&%S(&ED96]L;V=U
M92!F;W(-AT-=&AE("!.97<-AT-3&%B;W5R(%!A<G1Y+"!D96%L<R!W:71H('1H92!Q
M=65S=&EO;B!O9B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N(&9R;VT-AT-82!D:69F97)E;G0-AT-8VQA
M<W,-AT-<W1A;F1P;VEN="X-AT-2&4-AT-87)T:6-U;&%T97,-AT-=&AE(&9E87(-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE
M(&UI9&1L92!C;&%S<V5S(&%T('=H870-AT-;6EG:'0-AT-;V-C=7(-AT-:68-AT-=&AE($YE
M=R!2:6=H="`H;F5O+6QI8F5R86PI(&%G96YD82!S=6-C965D<RX-AT-)TEF('1H
M97)E(&%R92!N;R!R96%L(&5C;VYO;6EC(&%N9"!P;VQI=&EC86P-AT-8VAO:6-E
M<U]T:&4-AT-=V%Y(&ES(&]P96X-AT-9F]R('1H92!R971U<FX-AT-;V8-AT-=&]T86QI=&%R
M:6%N('!A<G1I97,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(')I9VAT(&%N9"!L969T+B<-AT-2&4-AT-9F5A<G,-AT-
M=&AE(&-O;G-E<75E;F-E<R!O9B!S;V-I86P-AT-8G)E86MD;W=N+B`-AT-2&5N8V4-AT-
M:&ES(&-O;F-E<FX-AT-=&\-AT-<&QA>2!D;W=N('1H92!I;7!A8W0-AT-;V8-AT-9VQO8F%L
M:7-A=&EO;BP-AT-87)G=6EN9R!T:&%T(&=O=F5R;FUE;G1S(&-A;B!C;RUO<F1I
M;F%T92!T:&5I<B`-AT-<&]L:6-I97,-AT-=&\-AT-;6%N86=E(&ET+"!T;R!P<F5V96YT
M('1H92!E>'1R96UE(&-O;G-E<75E;F-E<R!O9B!A;B!U;G)E<W1R86EN960-AT-
M;6%R:V5T(&%N9"!T;R!C<F5A=&4-AT-82!L97-S(&1E9V5N97)A=&4-AT-8V%P:71A
M;&ES;2X-"-AT-T*5&AE(')E;&%T:79E('!R;W-P97)I='D-AT-:6X-AT-0G)I=&%I;B!D
M=7)I;F<-AT-=&AE('!O<W0M=V%R(&)O;VT-AT-9V%V92!R:7-E('1O(&YE=R!P<FEV
M:6QE9V5D('-E8W1I;VYS(&]F('1H92!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S("T-AT-82!N97<-AT-
M;6ED9&QE(&-L87-S+B!4:&ES(&QA>65R(&]F('!R961O;6EN86YT;'D-AT-961U
M8V%T960L('-A;&%R:65D+"!W:&ET92!C;VQL87(-AT-=V]R:V5R<R!G<F5W('=I
M=&-AT--AT-=&AE(&5X<&%N<VEO;B!O9B!T:&4-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-86YD('-E<G9I8V5S('-E
M8W1O<B!A;F0L(&EN('1H92!M;W)E(')E8V5N="!P97)I;V0L('=I=&-AT--AT-=&AE
M(&EN9F]R;6%T:6]N('1E8VAN;VQO9WD-AT-<F5V;VQU=&EO;BX-AT-4W5S=&%I;FEN
M9R!I=',-AT-<')I=FEL96=E<R!I<R!T:&4-AT-:V5Y('1O('-O8VEA;"!S=&%B:6QI
M='D-AT-:6X-AT-86QL('1H92!M86IO<B!C87!I=&%L:7-T(&YA=&EO;G,-AT-86YD('!L
M87EI;F<-AT-=&\-AT-:71S('!R96IU9&EC97,-AT-:7,-AT-=&AE(&YE8V5S<V%R>2!C;VYD
M:71I;VX-AT-9F]R('!O;&ET:6-A;"!P87)T:65S('1O(&)E(&5L96-T960-AT-=&\-AT-
M<&]W97(N($%S(&QO;F<-AT-87,-AT-=&AE<F4-AT-=V5R92!S=69F:6-I96YT('!R;V9I
M=',-AT-9G)O;2!P<F]D=6-T:6]N(&%T(&AO;64-AT-86YD('1R861E(&%N9"!I;G9E
M<W1M96YT(&%B<F]A9"P-AT-8F]T:"!T;R!G:79E(&%N(&%D97%U871E(')E='5R
M;B!T;R!C87!I=&%L+"!A;F0-AT-=&\-AT-9FEN86YC92!S=&%T92!W96QF87)E(&%N
M9"!T:&4-AT-9W)O=VEN9R!U;G!R;V1U8W1I=F4-AT-<')I=F%T92!S96-T;W(L('1H
M96X-AT-=&AE('-O8VEA;"!D96UO8W)A=&EC(&-O;G-E;G-U<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-<&]S
M="!W87(-AT->65A<G,-AT-8V]U;&0-AT-8F4-AT-;6%I;G1A:6YE9"X-AT-270-AT-=V%S('!O<W-I
M8FQE('1O(&=U87)A;G1E92!T:&4-AT-<F5L871I=F5L>2!P<FEV:6QE9V5D(&-O
M;F1I=&EO;G,-AT-;V8-AT-:&EG:&5R('!A:60-AT-=V]R:V5R<R!A;F0-AT-=&AE(&UI9&1L
M92!C;&%S<V5S('=H:6QE('-U<W1A:6YI;F<-AT-861E<75A=&4-AT-;&EV:6YG('-T
M86YD87)D<R!F;W(-AT-=&AE(&UA<W,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('=O<FMI;F<-AT-8VQA<W,N(`T*
M#0I);B!T:&4-AT-;F5W(&-O;F1I=&EO;G,-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;"!S=&%G;F%T:6]N
M(&%N9"!G<F]W:6YG(&EN=&5R+6EM<&5R:6%L:7-T(')I=F%L<FEE<R!I;B!T
M:&4-AT-;6ED9&QE(&]F('1H92`Q.3<P<RP-AT-=&AI<R!C;VYS96YS=7,-AT-8F5G86X-AT-
M=&\-AT-8G)E86L-AT-9&]W;BX-AT-5&AE(#$Y-S0M-SD-AT-3&%B;W5R(&=O=F5R;FUE;G0-AT-
M<V5T(&UO;F5T87)Y('1A<F=E=',-AT-86YD(&-U="!S=&%T92!S<&5N9&EN9RX-AT-
M5&AE(&QO=RUP86ED('-T871E('-E8W1O<B!W;W)K97)S(&9O=6=H="!B86-K
M(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-)W=I;G1E<B!O9B!D:7-C;VYT96YT)RP-AT-,3DW."\Y+"!D<F]V
M92!T:&4-AT-:&EG:&5R('!A:60-AT-<VMI;&QE9"!W;W)K97)S(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-;6ED
M9&QE(&-L87-S97,-AT-:6YT;R!T:&4-AT-87)M<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-5&]R>2!087)T>2X-AT-
M5&AA=&-H97(-AT-96UB<F%C960-AT-=&AI<R!N97<-AT-8V]N<W1I='5E;F-Y(&%N9"P-AT-
M87,-AT-2'5T=&]N('-A>7,L("=T:&4-AT-;&EB97)A;"!P<F]F97-S:6]N<RP-AT-869F
M;'5E;G0-AT-8V]U;F-I;"!H;W5S92!T96YA;G1S+"!H;VUE;W=N97)S+"!A;&P-AT-
M8F5N969I=&5D(&9R;VT-AT-:&5R('1A>"!C=71S+"!C<F5D:70-AT-8F]O;2!A;F0-AT-
M<')I=F%T:7-A=&EO;B!P<F]G<F%M;64N)R!4:&4-AT-<')I8V4-AT-=V%S("!G<F]W
M:6YG(&EN97%U86QI='D-AT-87,-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-=V5L9F%R92!W87,-AT-8W5T(&%N9"!M
M:6QL:6]N<R!O9B!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S('!E;W!L92!W97)E(&1R:79E;B!I
M;G1O('!O=F5R='D-AT-=&\-AT-<&%Y(&9O<B!4:&%T8VAE<B=S('!R;V=R86UM92X-AT-
M5&AE('!R:79I;&5G97,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&UI9&1L92!C;&%S<V5S(&-O=6QD("!O
M;FQY(&)E('!R97-E<G9E9"!A="!T:&4-AT-97AP96YS92!O9B!E=F5R(&EN8W)E
M87-I;F<-AT-;G5M8F5R<R!O9B`-AT-:6UP;W9E<FES:&5D('=O<FMI;F<-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-
M<&5O<&QE+B!);B!S<&ET92!O9B!T:&4-AT-<F5V96YU97,-AT-9G)O;2!.;W)T:"!3
M96$-AT-3VEL+"!P<F]D=6-T:79E(&EN=F5S=&UE;G0-AT-<W1A9VYA=&5D(&EN($)R
M:71A:6XL(&%N9"`-AT-<F5C;W)D(&%M;W5N=',-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;"!W97)E(&EN
M=F5S=&5D(&%B<F]A9"X-AT-0G)I=&%I;B!W87,-AT-<F%P:61L>2!B96-O;6EN9R!A
M(')E;G1I97(-AT-<W1A=&4N#0H-"E=I=&-AT--AT-=&AE(&9A:6QU<F4-AT-;V8-AT-5&AA=&-H
M97(G<R!E8V]N;VUI8R!P;VQI8VEE<R!A="!T:&4-AT-96YD(&]F('1H92`Q.3-AT-P
M<R!A;F0-AT-=VET:"!P;W9E<G1Y(&%N9"!I;F5Q=6%L:71Y(')A<&ED;'D-AT-86-C
M96QE<F%T:6YG+"!I;G)O861S(&)E9V%N('1O(&)E(&UA9&4-AT-:6YT;R!T:&4-AT-
M<W1A;F1A<F0-AT-;V8-AT-;&EV:6YG(&]F('-E8W1I;VYS(&]F('1H92!M:61D;&4-AT-
M8VQA<W-E<RX-AT-270-AT-:7,-AT-=&AE('!O=&5N=&EA;&QY(&5X<&QO<VEV92!C;VYS
M97%U96YC97,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AI<R!D979E;&]P;65N="!T:&%T(&1R:79E<R!(=71T
M;VXN($AE(&]F9F5R<R!H:7,-AT-86QT97)N871I=F4-AT-=&\-AT-)V=L;V)A;&ES871I
M;VXG+"!T;R!A;B!U;G)E<W1R86EN960-AT-86YD(&1E<F5G=6QA=&5D(&-A<&ET
M86QI<VTN($9I<G-T+"!H92!S87ES+"!W92!M=7-T(&%L=&5R('1H92!W87D-AT-
M=&AE($)R:71I<V-AT--AT-9FEN86YC:6%L('-Y<W1E;2!W;W)K<R`M(&5S<V5N=&EA
M;&QY(&9R;VT-AT-<V5E:VEN9R!H:6=H+"!L:7%U:60L('-H;W)T+71E<FT-AT-9V%I
M;G,L(&ER<F5S<&5C=&EV92!O9B!L;V-A=&EO;BP-AT-=&\-AT-9VEV:6YG(&$-AT-;&]N
M9RUT97)M(&-O;6UI=&UE;G0-AT-=&\-AT-<F5G96YE<F%T:6YG('1H92!P<F]D=6-T
M:79E(&)A<V4-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE($)R:71I<V-AT--AT-96-O;F]M>2`M(&$-AT-<')O8V5S<R!W
M:&EC:"P-AT-:&4-AT-<V%Y<RP-AT-<F5Q=6ER97,-AT-82!P;VQI=&EC86P-AT-<F5V;VQU=&EO
M;B!T;R!T86ME('!O=V5R(&%W87D-AT-9G)O;2!T:&4-AT-96YT<F5N8VAE9"`G8V]N
M<V5R=F%T:79E(&AE9V5M;VYY)RX-AT-0G)I=&%I;B!H87,-AT-=&\-AT-8F4-AT-=')A;G-F
M;W)M960-AT-:6YT;R!A(&AI9V-AT--AT-:6YV97-T;65N="P-AT-:&EG:"!G<F]W=&-AT--AT-96-O
M;F]M>2X-AT-4V5C;VYD+"!A(&-O86QI=&EO;B!S=7!P;W)T:6YG('-O8VEA;"!W
M96QF87)E(&AA<R!T;R!B92!R96)U:6QT+B!&;W(-AT-=&AI<R!T;R!H87!P96X-AT-
M=&AE(&UI9&1L92!C;&%S<V5S(&UU<W0-AT-;W!T(&EN+"!R871H97(-AT-=&AA;B!O
M<'0-AT-;W5T(&EN=&\-AT-=&AE('!R:79A=&ES960-AT-<')O=FES:6]N(&]F('1H92!N
M96\M;&EB97)A;"!A9V5N9&$N(%1H92!M:61D;&4-AT-8VQA<W-E<RP-AT-:&4-AT-87)G
M=65S+"!C86X-AT-8F4-AT-9VEV96X-AT-)V$-AT-=F5S=&5D(&EN=&5R97-T(&EN('1H92!E
M;G1I<F4-AT-<WES=&5M)R!B>2`G:6YC;W)P;W)A=&EN9R!I;F5Q=6%L:71Y(&EN
M=&\-AT-=&AE('!U8FQI8R!D;VUA:6XG+B!!(&-O<F4-AT-<WES=&5M(&9O<B!T:&4-AT-
M;6%S<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-=V]R:VEN9R!C;&%S<R!W:71H('1H92!M:61D;&4-AT-8VQA
M<W-E<R!A8FQE('1O(&)U>2!I;B!T:&4-AT-97AT<F$-AT-<75A;&ET>2!S97)V:6-E
M<R!T:&5Y(')E<75I<F4-AT-+2`-AT-:6X-AT-<VAO<G0-AT-("=N871I;VYA;&ES:6YG(&EN
M97%U86QI='DG('=I=&AI;B!T:&4-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-<WES=&5M+-AT-T*#0I(;W=E=F5R
M+"!I9B!T:&4-AT-9&5G96YE<F%T:6]N(&]F(&-A<&ET86QI<VT-AT-:6YT;R!A('!A
M<F%S:71I8R!A;F0-AT-<F5N=&EE<B!F;W)M(&ES(&YO=R!A(&YE8V5S<V%R>2!T
M<F5N9"!E;65R9VEN9R!I;B!A;&P-AT-=&AE(&UA='5R92!C87!I=&%L:7-T(&YA
M=&EO;G,L($AU='1O;B=S(')E<W!O;G-E('1O(&=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-+2!W
M:&%T("!)(&AA=F4-AT-8V%L;&5D('1H92`-AT-<&]L:71I8V%L(&5C;VYO;7D-AT-;V8-AT-
M=&AE(&YE=R!M:61D;&4-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-+2!I<R!B;W1H(&ED96%L:7-T(&%N9"!R
M96%C=&EO;F%R>2XT#0H-"E=E(&-A;B!N;W<-AT-=6YD97)S=&%N9"!T:&4-AT-<VEG
M;FEF:6-A;F-E(&]F(%-I=F%N86YD86XG<R!S=&%N9'!O:6YT+B!,:79I;F<-AT-
M:6X-AT-82!C;W5N=')Y("!W:&5R92`-AT-:VYO=VQE9&=E+"!C=6QT=7)E(&%N9"!P
M;VQI=&EC<R!A<F4-AT-9&]M:6YA=&5D(&)Y('1H92!C;VYC97)N<R!A;F0-AT-<')E
M:G5D:6-E<R!O9B!M:61D;&4-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-<&5O<&QE.R!I;B!W:&EC:"!T:&4-AT-
M<&]O<B!A;F0-AT-;W!P<F5S<V5D('=O<FMI;F<-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-87)E(&]U='-I9&4-AT-
M=&AE('!O;&ET:6-A;"!P<F]C97-S(&%N9"!I9VYO<F5D(&)Y('1H92!O9F9I
M8VEA;"!L86)O=7(-AT-;6]V96UE;G0[(&%N9"!W:&5R92!S;V-I86P-AT-<F5L871I
M;VYS('-E96T-AT-9G)O>F5N+"!R97!E=&ET:79E(&%N9"!U;F-H86YG:6YG+"!I
M="!C;W5L9"!A<'!E87(-AT-=&AA="!A;B!E<&]C:&%L('-H:69T(&AA<R!O8V-U
M<G)E9"!I;B!C87!I=&%L:7-M(&%N9"!T:&%T('1H92!S;V-I86QI<W0-AT-<')O
M:F5C="P-AT-870-AT-;&5A<W0-AT-87,-AT-:70-AT-:7,-AT-=')A9&ET:6]N86QL>2!U;F1E<G-T
M;V]D+"!H87,-AT-=&\-AT-8F4-AT-8G5R:65D+B!792!N;W1E(%-I=F%N86YD86XG<R!W
M87)N:6YG(&YO="!T;R!U;F1E<F5S=&EM871E('1H92!D86YG97)S('!O<V5D
M(&)Y('1H92!S;RUC86QL960-AT-("=C=6QT=7)E(&]F('!O<W1M;V1E<FYI<VTG
M+"!I;B!A('-O8VEE='D-AT-=VAE<F4-AT-)R)K;F]W;&5D9V4-AT-=V]R:V5R<R(-AT-=VAO
M(')U;B!T:&4-AT-26YF;W)M871I;VX-AT-4V]C:65T>2P-AT-=VAO(&%R92!I;B!T:&4-AT-
M96YG:6YE(')O;VT-AT-;V8-AT-<&]W97(L(&AA=F4-AT-8F5C;VUE(&-O;&QA8F]R871O
M<G,-AT-:6X-AT-<&]W97(G+B!"=70-AT-=V4-AT-<F5S<&]N9"!A<R!M871E<FEA;&ES=',N
M($AI<W1O<GD-AT-:&%S(&YO="!E;F1E9"X-AT-06YD(&=L;V)A;&ES871I;VXL(&EF
M(&ET(&ES(&%N>71H:6YG+"!I<R!A('-I9VX-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&-R:7-I<R!O9B!C
M87!I=&%L:7-M+"!O9B`-AT-:6YC<F5A<VEN9R!I;G-T86)I;&ET>2P-AT-;V8-AT-<F%P
M:61L>2!C:&%N9VEN9R!C:7)C=6US=&%N8V5S("!I;B!A('=O<FQD(&]F(&]B
M<V-E;F4-AT-86YD(&=R;W=I;F<-AT-:6YE<75A;&ET>2X-AT-4V]C:6%L(')E;&%T:6]N
M<R!A<F4-AT-;F]T(&9I>&5D+B!4:&4-AT-8V]N9&ET:6]N<R!W:&EC:"!S<&%W;F5D
M(&$-AT-;F5W(&UI9&1L92!C;&%S<R!A;F0-AT-='5R;F5D(&ET(&EN=&\-AT-82!B961R
M;V-K(&]F('-O8VEA;"!S=&%B:6QI='D-AT-:6X-AT-=&AE(&EM<&5R:6%L:7-T(&YA
M=&EO;G,-AT-869T97(-AT-=&AE('=A<B!H879E(&5N9&5D+B!4;V1A>2!I="!I<R!T
M:&]S92!P<FEV:6QE9V5D(&-O;F1I=&EO;G,-AT-=VAI8V-AT--AT-87)E(&)E:6YG('1H
M<F5A=&5N960N($AU='1O;BP-AT-870-AT-;&5A<W0L(')E8V]G;FES97,-AT-=&AI<R`M
M(&AE;F-E(&AI<R!T97)R:6)L92!F96%R(&]F(&$-AT-<F5T=7)N('1O('1H92!E
M>'1R96UE<R!O9B!C;&%S<R!C;VYF;&EC="!T:&%T(&1O;6EN871E9"!T:&4-AT-
M,3DS,',N("!3:79A;F%N9&%N(&ES(&9A<B!T;V\-AT-<')E;V-C=7!I960-AT-=VET
M:"!T:&4-AT-:61E;VQO9VEC86P-AT-<&]S='5R:6YG(&]F(&$-AT-<VUA;&P-AT-96QI=&4-AT-
M;V8-AT-86-A9&5M:6-S(&%N9"!O<&EN:6]N(&9O<FUE<G,-AT-8V%U9VAT('5P('=I
M=&-AT--AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B!A;F0-AT-8F5N969I8VEA<FEE<R!O9B!I="X-"-AT-T*
M16QL96X-AT-365I:W-I;G,-AT-5V]O9"!D979E;&]P<R!A(&YU;6)E<B!O9B!C<G5C
M:6%L('!O:6YT<R!I;B!H97(-AT-<F5P;'D-AT-=&\-AT-4VEV86YA;F1A;BX-AT-1FER<W1L
M>2P-AT-(&UO<F4-AT-9VEA;G0-AT-8V]R<&]R871I;VYS('=I=&-AT--AT-82!G;&]B86P-AT-<F5A
M8V-AT-L(&%N9"!M;W)E(&EN=&5R;F%T:6]N86P-AT-;W)G86YI<V%T:6]N<R!S97)V
M:6YG('1H92!I;G1E<F5S=',-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A;"P-AT-:6X-AT-;F\-AT-=V%Y(&EM<&QY
M(&$-AT-=6YI9FEE9"!I;G1E<FYA=&EO;F%L(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-8VQA<W,N(%1H
M92`G9VQO8F%L)R!M87)K970-AT-96YS=7)E<R!T:&4-AT-)VEN=&5R;F%T:6]N86QI
M<V%T:6]N(&]F(&-O;7!E=&ET:6]N)R`M(&$-AT-8V]N=')A9&EC=&]R>2!P<F]C
M97-S+B!/;B!T:&4-AT-;VYE(&AA;F0-AT-:70-AT-9&]E<R!M96%N(&YE=R!F;W)M<R!O
M9B!C87!I=&%L:7-T(&EN=&5G<F%T:6]N(&%N9"!C;RUO<&5R871I;VX-AT-86-R
M;W-S(&YA=&EO;F%L(&)O=6YD87)I97,-AT-8G5T(&]N('1H92!O=&AE<B!H86YD
M+"!I="!A;'-O(&UE86YS(&%C=&EV92!C;VUP971I=&EO;B!B971W965N(&YA
M=&EO;F%L(&%N9"!R96=I;VYA;"!C87!I=&%L:7-T<RX-AT-)U-O('1H92`G9VQO
M8F%L)R!E8V]N;VUY(&EF(&%N>71H:6YG(&UA>2!M96%N(&QE<W,-AT-86YD(&YO
M="!M;W)E(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-=6YI='DN)R!4:&4-AT-;W9E<F%L;"!C;VYS97%U
M96YC92!O9B`G9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B<-AT-9F%R(&9R;VT-AT-:6YT96=R871I;F<-AT-
M8V%P:71A;"!I<R!A="!L96%S="!A<R!L:6ME;'D-AT-=&\-AT-<')O9'5C92!D:7-I
M;G1E9W)A=&EO;BX-AT-#0H-"E-E8V]N9&QY+"!T:&4-AT-<')O<&]S:71I;VX-AT-=&AA
M="!T:&5R92!I<R!A;B!I;G9E<G-E(')E;&%T:6]N(&)E='é6X-AT-=&AE(&EN
M=&5R;F%T:6]N86QI<V%T:6]N(&]F('1H92!E8V]N;VUY(&%N9"!T:&4-AT-<&]W
M97(-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('-T871E(&9A:6QS('1O(&%C:VYO=VQE9&=E('1H870-AT-)V=L
M;V)A;&ES871I;VXG('!R97-U<'!O<V5S('1H92!S=&%T92X-AT-)U1H92!N871I
M;VXM<W1A=&4-AT-:7,-AT-=&AE(&UA:6X-AT-8V]N9'5I="!T:')O=6=H('=H:6-H(&YA
M=&EO;F%L("AO<B!I;F1E960-AT-;75L=&EN871I;VYA;"D-AT-8V%P:71A;"!I<R!I
M;G-E<G1E9"!I;G1O('1H92!G;&]B86P-AT-;6%R:V5T+B<-AT-5')A;G-N871I;VYA
M;"!C87!I=&%L(&UA>2!B92!M;W)E(&5F9F5C=&EV92!T:&%N('1H92!O;&0M
M<W1Y;&4-AT-;6EL:71A<GD-AT-:6UP97)I86QI<VT-AT-:6X-AT-<&5N971R871I;F<-AT-979E
M<GD-AT-8V]R;F5R(&]F('1H92!W;W)L9"!B=70-AT-:70-AT-86-C;VUP;&ES:&5S('1H
M:7,L(&EN('1H92!M86EN+"!T:')O=6=H('1H92!M961I=6T-AT-;V8-AT-;&]C86P-AT-
M8V%P:71A;"!A;F0-AT-;&]C86P-AT-<W1A=&5S+B!)="!M87D-AT-=V5L;"P-AT-=6QT:6UA
M=&5L>2P-AT-<F5L>2!O;B!T:&4-AT-;6EL:71A<GD-AT-<&]W97(-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&QA<W0-AT-
M<F5M86EN:6YG("=S=7!E<BUP;W=E<B<-AT-=&\-AT-<W5S=&%I;B!T:&4-AT-<V]V97)E
M:6=N='D-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&UA<FME="X-AT-1G5R=&AE<BP-AT-:70-AT-9&5P96YD<R!O;B!S
M=6-H(&QO8V%L('!O;&ET:6-A;"!J=7)I<V1I8W1I;VYS('1O(&UA:6YT86EN
M('1H92!C;VYD:71I;VYS(&]F(&5C;VYO;6EC('-T86)I;&ET>2!A;F0-AT-(&QA
M8F]U<B!D:7-C:7!L:6YE('=H:6-H(&%R92!T:&4-AT-8V]N9&ET:6]N<R!F;W(-AT-
M<')O9FET86)L92!I;G9E<W1M96YT+B!!;F0-AT-9FEN86QL>2P-AT-;F5W(&MI;F1S
M(&]F(&EN=&5R+6EM<&5R:6%L:7-T(')I=F%L<GD-AT-=VEL;"!E;65R9V4-AT-:6X-AT-
M=VAI8V-AT--AT-=&AE(&YA=&EO;B!S=&%T92!I<R!S=&EL;"!T:&4-AT-<')I;F-I<&%L
M(&%G96YT+-AT-T*#0I&<F]M('1H:7,-AT-<VAE(&%D=F%N8V5S(&AE<B!M;W-T(&EM
M<&]R=&%N="!P;VQI=&EC86P-AT-<&]I;G0Z('1H92!N871I;VX-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-:7,-AT-
M<W1I;&P-AT-=&AE('1E<G)A:6X-AT-;V8-AT-("AC;&%S<RD-AT-<W1R=6=G;&4N("=)9B!T
M:&4-AT-<W1A=&4-AT-:7,-AT-=&AE(&-H86YN96P-AT-=&AR;W5G:"!W:&EC:"!C87!I=&%L
M(&UO=F5S(&EN('1H92`B9VQO8F%L:7-E9"(-AT-96-O;F]M>2P-AT-=&AE;B!I="!I
M<R!E<75A;&QY('1H92!M96%N<R!B>2!W:&EC:"!A;B!A;G1I+6-A<&ET86QI
M<W0-AT-9F]R8V4-AT-8V]U;&0-AT-<V5V97(-AT-8V%P:71A;"=S(&QI9F5L:6YE+B<-AT-#0H-
M"E1H97-E(&%R9W5M96YT<R!G;R!A(&=R96%T(&1E86P-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('=A>2!T
M;R!U;F1E<FUI;FEN9R!3:79A;F%N9&%N)W,-AT-<&]S:71I;VXN($)U="!T:&5R
M92!I<R!S;VUE=&AI;F<-AT-;&%C:VEN9RX-AT-270-AT-:7,-AT-<&5R:&%P<R!B97-T(&AI
M9VAL:6=H=&5D(&EN('1H92!U;F1U92!W96EG:'0-AT-5V]O9"!G:79E<R!T;R!T
M:&4-AT-:61E;VQO9VEC86P-AT-:6UP86-T(&]F('1H92!C;VYC97!T(&]F(&=L;V)A
M;&ES871I;VX-AT-87,-AT-:70-AT-:7,-AT-8V]M;6]N;'D-AT-=6YD97)S=&]O9"X-AT-)TET(&ES
M('1H92!H96%V:65S="!A;&)A=')O<W,-AT-87)O=6YD('1H92!N96-K(&]F('1H
M92!L969T('1O9&%Y)RX-AT-)TEN('1H92!C=7)R96YT(&-O;F-E<'1I;VX-AT-;V8-AT-
M9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;BP-AT-;&5F="!J;VEN<R!R:6=H="!I;B!A8V-E<'1I;F<-AT-
M=&AA="`-AT-(E1H97)E($ES($YO($%L=&5R;F%T:79E(B`M(&YO="!J=7-T('1O
M(&-A<&ET86QI<VTL(&)U=%]T;R!A(&UO<F4-AT-;W(-AT-;&5S<R`H=&AE(')I9VAT
M(&=O97,-AT-9F]R(&UO<F4L('1H92!L969T('-O;65W:&%T(&QE<W,I(')U=&AL
M97-S;'D-AT-(F9L97AI8FQE(B!C87!I=&%L:7-M+B<-AT-4VAE(&-O;G1I;G5E<RP-AT-
M:68-AT-=&AE:7(-AT-8V]N8V5P=&EO;B!O9B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N('=E<F4-AT-86X-AT-
M86-C=7)A=&4-AT-<F5F;&5C=&EO;B!O9B!W:&%T('=A<R!H87!P96YI;F<-AT-:6X-AT-
M=&AE('=O<FQD('1O9&%Y(&AE<B!I9&5O;&]G:6-A;"!O8FIE8W1I;VYS('=O
M=6QD;B=T(&-O=6YT(&9O<B!M=6-H(&%N9"!W92!W;W5L9"!H879E('1O(&%C
M8V5P="!T:&%T('1H92!S;V-I86QI<W0-AT-<')O:F5C="!I<R!D96%D+B`-"-AT-T*
M5&AI<R!I<R!A;&P-AT-=F5R>2!T<G5E(&)U="!S;VUE=&AI;F<-AT-;6]R92!I<R!S
M=7)E;'D-AT-;F5E9&5D+B!)9&5A<R!O;FQY(&)E8V]M92!A(&UA=&5R:6%L(&9O
M<F-E('=H96X-AT-=&%K96X-AT-=7`-AT-8GD-AT-=&AE(&UA<W-E<RX-AT-5&AE(&ED96]L;V=I
M8V%L('-T<G5G9VQE(&ES(&]F('!O;&ET:6-A;"!I;7!O<G1A;F-E('=H96X-AT-
M(&ET(&9A;&QS(&]N(&9E<G1I;&4-AT-9W)O=6YD+B!);B`-AT-<&5R:6]D<R!W:&5N
M('1H92!P;V]R(&%N9"!I;7!O=F5R:7-H960-AT-=V]R:VEN9R!C;&%S<R!A<F4-AT-
M;W5T<VED92!T:&4-AT-<&]L:71I8V%L('!R;V-E<W,L('1H92!P;VQI=&EC<R!O
M9B!T:&4-AT-;&5F="P-AT-:6X-AT-=&AE(&UA:6XL(')E9FQE8W0-AT-=&AE:7(-AT-8VQA<W,-AT-
M<&]S:71I;VX-AT-:6X-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES="!S;V-I971Y("T-AT-87,-AT-<&%R="!O9B!T
M:&4-AT-<')I=FEL96é"!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S(&]R(&5D=6-A=&5D('=H:71E
M(&-O;&QA<B!A;F0-AT-<')O9F5S<VEO;F%L('=O<FME<G,-AT-=VAO(&9O<FT-AT-=&AE
M(&)A8VMB;VYE(&]F('1H92!N97<-AT-;6ED9&QE(&-L87-S+B!4:&4-AT-<F5C;VUP
M;W-I=&EO;B!O9B!T:&4-AT-=V]R:VEN9R!C;&%S<R!A<R!A(&9I9VAT:6YG(&9O
M<F-E(&%G86EN<W0-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES;2!H87,-AT-=&\-AT-8F4-AT-=&AE('!R;V1U8W0-AT-
M;V8-AT-9&5V96QO<&UE;G1S('=I=&AI;B!C87!I=&%L:7-M(&ET<V5L9BP-AT-:70-AT-
M=VEL;"!N;W0-AT-8F4-AT-=&AE(')E<W5L="!O9B`-AT-:61E;VQO9VEC86P-AT-8V]M8F%T
M(&%L;VYE+B!4:&ES('!R;V-E<W,-AT-:7,-AT-86QR96%D>2!T86MI;F<-AT-<&QA8V4-AT-
M87,-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES="!G;W9E<FYM96YT<R!D97)E9W5L871E(&QA8F]U<BP-AT-
M871T86-K('-T871E('=E;&9A<F4L('5N9&5R;6EN92!T:&4-AT-9&5M;V-R871I
M8R!R:6=H="!T;R!P<F]T97-T(&%N9"!W;W)K97)S)R!R:6=H=',-AT-=&\-AT-;W)G
M86YI<V4L(&%T=&5M<'0-AT-=&\-AT-9&EV:61E('1H92!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S('1H
M<F]U9V-AT--AT-<F%C:7-M(&%N9"!S97AI<VTL(&%N9"!D97-T<F]Y('1H92!E;G9I
M<F]N;65N="X-AT-5&AE(&ED96]L;V=I8V%L('-T<G5G9VQE(&AA<R!T;R!B92!C
M;VUB:6YE9"!W:71H('1H92!P;VQI=&EC86P-AT-;W)G86YI<V%T:6]N(&%N9"!D
M969E;F-E(&]F('1H;W-E('-E8W1I;VYS(&]F('1H92!W;W)K:6YG(&-L87-S
M('5N9&5R(&%T=&%C:R!A;F0-AT-9FEG:'1I;F<-AT-8F%C:RX-AT-5V4-AT-;F5E9"!T;R!S
M:&]W(&AO=R!D979E;&]P;65N=',-AT-=VET:&EN(&-A<&ET86QI<VT-AT-87)E(&UA
M:VEN9R!T:&ES('!O<W-I8FQE+B!4:&%T(&ES('=H>2!A(&=R96%T(&1E86P-AT-
M;6]R92!I<R!R97%U:7)E9"!F<F]M("!T:&4-AT-86YA;'ES:7,-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&QA
M=&5S="!S=&%G92!O9B!C87!I=&%L:7-M('1O("!F:6YA;&QY(&QA>2!T;R!R
M97-T('1H92!G:&]S="!O9B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N+-AT-T*#0I4:&4-AT-<F5A;&ET
M>2!O9B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N#0H-"DET(&ES(&EM<&]R=&%N="!N;W0-AT-=&\-AT-
M=6YD97)E<W1I;6%T92!T:&4-AT-<VEG;FEF:6-A;F-E(&]F(&=L;V)A;&ES871I
M;VXN($ET(&UI9VAT('=E;&P-AT-8F4-AT-86X-AT-)VED96]L;V=I8V%L(&UY<W1I9FEC
M871I;VXG(&EN('1H92!H86YD<R!O9B!A($UA<G1I;B!7;VQF(&]R('-O;64-AT-
M:6YT96QL96-T=6%L<R!A;F0-AT-86-A9&5M:6-S("!O;B!T:&4-AT-<&]L:71I8V%L
M(&QE9G0L(&)U="!I=',-AT-:6UP86-T(&]N('1H92!E8V]N;VUI8R!A;F0-AT-<&]L
M:71I8V%L(&QI=F5S(&]F('1H92!V87-T(&UA:F]R:71Y(&]F(&AU;6%N:71Y
M(&ES(&]F(&=R96%T('!O;&ET:6-A;"!C;VYS97%U96YC92X-AT-5&\-AT-<V%Y+"!A
M<R!)(&AA=F4-AT-87)G=65D(&EN(&UY(&5A<FQI97(-AT-87)T:6-L92!O;B!G;&]B
M86QI<V%T:6]N+"!T:&%T("=F87(-AT-9G)O;2!I="!B96EN9R!N97<-AT-:70-AT-:7,-AT-
M82!R971U<FX-AT-=&\-AT-=&AO<V4-AT-=6YS=&%B;&4-AT-9F5A='5R97,-AT-;V8-AT-8V%P:71A
M;&ES;2!W:&EC:"!C:&%R86-T97)I<V5D(&EM<&5R:6%L:7-M(&)E9F]R92!T
M:&4-AT-1FER<W0-AT-5V]R;&0-AT-5V%R)R!I<R!N;W0-AT-=&\-AT-9&ES;6ES<R!I=',-AT-:6UP
M;W)T86YC92!B=70L(&]N('1H92!C;VYT<F%R>2P-AT-=&\-AT-:&EG:&QI9VAT(&ET
M+B!)="!I<R!B96=I;FYI;F<-AT-=&\-AT-8W)E871E('1H92!V97)Y(&-O;F1I=&EO
M;G,-AT-=VAI8V-AT--AT-<')O9'5C960-AT-=&AO<V4-AT-9')A;6%T:6,-AT-<VAO8VMS('1O('1H
M92!I;G1E<FYA=&EO;F%L(&-A<&ET86QI<W0-AT-96-O;F]M>2!A;F0-AT-=VAI8V-AT--AT-
M;&5D('1O('1H92!R979O;'5T:6]N87)Y(&1E=F5L;W!M96YT<R!I;B!T:&4-AT-
M9FER<W0-AT-9&5C861E<R!O9B!T:&4-AT-='=E;G1I971H(&-E;G1U<GDN(%-O('=H
M870-AT-=&AE;B!A<F4-AT-=&AE(&-R=6-I86P-AT-8V]M<&]N96YT<R!O9B!G;&]B86QI
M<V%T:6]N('=H:6-H('-U9V=E<W0-AT-=&AE<V4-AT-9&5V96QO<&UE;G1S+-AT-T*#0KZ
M"4UU;'1I;F%T:6]N86P-AT-8V]M<&%N:65S("A-3D-S*6%R92!T:&4-AT-<')I;F-I
M<&QE('9E:&EC;&4-AT-;V8-AT-:6UP97)I86QI<VTG<R!D<FEV92!T;R!R961I=FED
M92!T:&4-AT-=V]R;&0-AT-86-C;W)D:6YG('1O(&5C;VYO;6EC('!O=V5R+B!);B`Q
M.3DU($9O<F5I9VX-AT-1&ER96-T($EN=F5S=&UE;G0-AT-*$9$22D-AT-;W5T9FQO=W,-AT-
M:6YC<F5A<V5D(&)Y(&$-AT-;6%S<VEV92`S."!P97(-AT-8V5N="!T;R`D,S$W8FXL
M('=I=&-AT--AT-82!R96-O<F0-AT-)#$P,&)N(&=O:6YG('1O(%1H:7)D(%=O<FQD(&-O
M=6YT<FEE<RX-AT-5&AA="!I;G9E<W1M96YT(&ES(&-O;F-E;G1R871E9"!I;B!T
M:')E92!C;VUP971I;F<-AT-<&]W97(-AT-8FQO8W,L('1H92`G5')I860G(&]F('1H
M92!%=7)O<&5A;B!5;FEO;BP-AT-2F%P86X-AT-86YD('1H92!5;FET960-AT-4W1A=&5S
M(&%N9"!T:&5I<B!R96=I;VYA;"!C;'5S=&5R(&]F(&-O=6YT<FEE<RX-AT--S8-AT-
M<&5R(&-E;G0-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&EN=F5S=&UE;G0-AT-:6X-AT-5&AI<F0-AT-5V]R;&0-AT-8V]U
M;G1R:65S("-AT-Q.3DS+34I('=E;G0-AT-=&\-AT-;VYL>2`Q,"!C;W5N=')I97,N($9I
M=F4-AT-:6UP97)I86QI<W0-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S+"`-AT-56YI=&5D(%-T871E<RP-AT-54LL
M($=E<FUA;GDL($IA<&%N(&%N9"!&<F%N8V4-AT-=V5R92!R97-P;VYS:6)L92!F
M;W(-AT-86QM;W-T('1W;RUT:&ER9',-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('1O=&%L(&]U=&9L;W=S(&EN
M(#$Y.34N(%1H92!5;FET960-AT-4W1A=&5S("-AT-D.39B;BDL(%5+("-AT-D,SAB;BD-AT-
M86YD($=E<FUA;GD-AT-*"0S-6)N*2!A;&P-AT-97AP;W)T960-AT-<F5C;W)D(&%M;W5N
M=',N-2`-AT-#0H)#0KZ"4UO<W0-AT-34Y#<R!A<F4-AT-;F%T:6]N86QL>2!B87-E9"P-AT-
M8V]N=')O;&QE9"!B>2!N871I;VYA;"!S:&%R96AO;&1E<G,L(&%N9"!T<F%D
M92!A;F0-AT-:6YV97-T(&UU;'1I;F%T:6]N86QL>2!W:71H(&$-AT-;&%R9V4-AT-;6%J
M;W)I='D-AT-;V8-AT-<V%L97,-AT-86YD(&%S<V5T<R!I;B!T:&5I<B!H;VUE(&-O=6YT
M<GDN($$-AT-<F5C96YT('-T=61Y('-H;Wé"`W,"`M(#<U('!E<B!C96YT('9A
M;'5E(&%D9&5D(&)Y(&UU;'1I;F%T:6]N86P-AT-8V]M<&%N:65S('=A<R!P<F]D
M=6-E9"!I;B!T:&4-AT-:&]M92!C;W5N=')Y+B!4:&5Y(&%R92!H:6=H;'D-AT-8V]N
M8V5N=')A=&5D+B!/;FQY(#$P,"!-3D-S+"`P+C,-AT-<&5R(&-E;G0-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE
M('1O=&%L+"!A;&P-AT-9G)O;2!I;7!E<FEA;&ES="!C;W5N=')I97,L(&]W;B!O
M;F4M=&AI<F0-AT-*"0Q+C0-AT-=')I;&QI;VXI(&]F('1H92!T;W1A;"!&1$D-AT-:6YV
M97-T;65N="!S=&]C:RX-AT-5&AE('!R;V-E<W,-AT-;V8-AT-8V]N8V5N=')A=&EO;B!C
M;VYT:6YU97,-AT-:6YT97)N871I;VYA;&QY('1H<F]U9V-AT--AT-;65R9V5R<R!A;F0-AT-
M86-Q=6ES:71I;VYS+B!#<F]S<R!B;W)D97(-AT-;65R9V5R<R!A;F0-AT-86-Q=6ES
M:71I;VYS(&1O=6)L960-AT-8F5T=V5E;B`Q.3-AT-X(&%N9"`Q.3DU('1O("0R,C5B
M;BX-AT-#0KZ"4=L;V)A;&ES871I;VX-AT-:7,-AT-9&5V87-T871I;F<-AT-=&AE(&QI=F5S
M(&]F(&UI;&QI;VYS(&]F('!E;W!L92X-AT-179E;B!T:&4-AT-5V]R;&0-AT-0F%N:R!A
M9&UI=',-AT-=&AA="!I;B!T:&4-AT-8V%S92!O9B!T:&4-AT-97-AT-M4V]V:65T(&)L;V,-AT-
M)W1R86YS:71I;VX-AT-:&%S(')E;&5G871E9"!A;B!E;G1I<F4-AT-9V5N97)A=&EO
M;B!T;R!E8V]N;VUI8R!I9&QE;F5S<RXG("!/=71P=70-AT-:6X-AT-4G5S<VEA(&9E
M;&P-AT-8GD-AT--#`-AT-<&5R(&-E;G0-AT-8F5T=V5E;B`Q.3DP("TQ.3DU(&%N9"!B971W
M965N(#$V(&%N9"`S,"!P97(-AT-8V5N="!I;B!T:&4-AT-;W1H97(-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S
M+B!'<F]W=&-AT--AT-:&%S(&)E96X-AT-9F%L;&EN9R!O=F5R('1H92!L87-T(#$U('EE
M87)S(&EN(&%B;W5T(#$P,"!C;W5N=')I97,L('=I=&-AT--AT-86QM;W-T(&$-AT-=&AI
M<F0-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE('=O<FQD)W,-AT-<&5O<&QE+"!D<F%M871I8V%L;'D-AT-<F5D=6-I
M;F<-AT-=&AE(&EN8V]M97,-AT-;V8-AT-,2XV8FX-AT-<&5O<&QE+B`-AT-5&AE(&1E8VQI;F5S
M(&%R92!U;G!R96-E9&5N=&5D+"!E>&-E961I;F<-AT-:6X-AT-9'5R871I;VX-AT-86YD
M('-O;65T:6UE<R!I;B!D97!T:"!T:&4-AT-1W)E870-AT-1&5P<F5S<VEO;B!O9B!T
M:&4-AT-,3DS,',N($]N92!B:6QL:6]N('!E;W!L92P-AT-,S`-AT-<&5R(&-E;G0-AT-;V8-AT-
M=&AE('=O<FQD)W,-AT-=V]R:V9O<F-E+"!A<F4-AT-96ET:&5R(&IO8FQE<W,-AT-;W(-AT-
M=6YE;7!L;WEE9"X-AT-179E;B!I;B!T:&4-AT-:6UP97)I86QI<W0-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S
M(#$P,&T-AT-<&5O<&QE(&QI=F4-AT-8F5L;W<-AT-=&AE('!O=F5R='D-AT-;&EN92P-AT-,S!M
M(&%R92!U;F5M<&QO>65D(&%N9"!M;W)E('1H86X-AT--6T-AT-87)E(&AO;65L97-S
M+C8-"OH)5&AE('=O<FQD(&ES(&)E8V]M:6YG(&UO<F4-AT-=6YS=&%B;&4N("`D
M,2PR,S!B;B!A(&1A>2!F;&]W<R!T:')O=6=H('1H92!F;W)E:6=N(&5X8VAA
M;F=E(&UA<FME=',N(%1H:7)D(%=O<FQD($1E8G0L(&%T(&$-AT-<F5C;W)D("0Q
M+#DT,&)N+"`-AT-8V]N=&EN=65S('1O(&EN8W)E87-E(&1E<W!I=&4-AT-;6%S<VEV
M92!D96)T(')E<&%Y;65N="X-AT-02!F;W)M:61A8FQE("0U-2!T<FEL;&EO;B!I
M<R!G86UB;&5D(&]N('1H92!W;W)L9"=S(&1E<FEV871I=F5S(&UA<FME="X-AT-
M06QL('1H92!M86IO<B!B86YK<R!A<F4-AT-;&%R9V4-AT-<&QA>65R<RX-AT-0F%R8VQA
M>7,L(&9O<B!E>&%M<&QE+"!H87,-AT-;&EA8FEL:71I97,-AT-;V8-AT-G#DR,F)N+"`-AT-
M;6]R92!T:&%N(#-AT-P('1I;65S(&ET<R!C87!I=&%L(&)A<V4N($$-AT-8W)A<V-AT--AT-
M:6X-AT-=&AE('-T;V-K;6%R:V5T('=I;&P-AT-;&5A=F4-AT-=&AE;2!F86-I;F<-AT-:'5G
M92!L;W-S97,N($=R;W=T:"!I;B!W;W)L9"!T<F%D92!H86QV960-AT-;&%S="!Y
M96%R(&)E8V%U<V4-AT-;V8-AT-82!S:&%R<"!D971E<FEO<F%T:6]N(&EN('1H92!P
M97)F;W)M86YC92!O9B!T:&4-AT-<V\M8V%L;&5D($%S:6%N("=T:6=E<G,G+B!4
M:&4-AT-8V]N9FQI8W0-AT-:6X-AT-6F%I<F4-AT-:&%S('-T87)T960-AT-82!N97<-AT-<V-R86UB
M;&4-AT-9F]R($%F<FEC82!A<R!I;G1E<BUI;7!E<FEA;&ES="!R:79A;')Y(&EN
M=&5N<VEF:65S+B!&:6YA;&QY+"!I;F5Q=6%L:71Y(&)E='é6X-AT-<FEC:"!A
M;F0-AT-<&]O<B!C;W5N=')I97,-AT-86YD(&)E='é6X-AT-<FEC:"!A;F0-AT-<&]O<B!I
M;B!A;&P-AT-8V]U;G1R:65S(&AA<R!R96%C:&5D('5N<')E8V5D96YT960-AT-;&5V
M96QS(&%N9"!I<R!S=&EL;"!G<F]W:6YG+-AT-T*#0I4:&5S92!A<F4-AT-;F]T('1H
M92!C;VYD:71I;VYS(&]F(&%N('5N8VAA;F=I;F<-AT-=V]R;&0N("!4:&5Y(&%R
M92!O;F4G<R!W:&5R92!T:&4-AT-<V]C:6%L:7-T(&UE<W-A9V4-AT-8V%N(&]N8V4-AT-
M86=A:6X-AT-=&%K92!R;V]T+B!4:')O=6=H;W5T('1H92!W;W)L9"P-AT-9G)O;2`-AT-
M=V]R:V5R<R!I;B!+;W)E82!T;R!G=65R<FEL;&%S(&EN($UE>&EC;RP-AT-9G)O
M;2!P=6)L:6,-AT-<V5C=&]R('=O<FME<G,-AT-:6X-AT-1G)A;F-E('1O(&QA;F1L97-S
M('!E87-A;G1S(&EN($)R87II;"P-AT-<&5O<&QE(&%R92!F:6=H=&EN9R!F;W(-AT-
M8VAA;F=E+B!);B!"<FET86EN(&YE=R!A;&QI86YC97,-AT-87)E(&)E:6YG(&)U
M:6QT('=I=&-AT--AT-96YV:7)O;FUE;G1A;"!C86UP86EG;F5R<R!T86MI;F<-AT-=&\-AT-
M=&AE('-T<F5E=',-AT-=&\-AT-9&5F96YD(&1O8VME<G,-AT-:6X-AT-3&EV97)P;V]L+B!'
M;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N(&ES(&$-AT-;&]N9RUT97)M('-T<G5C='5R86P-AT-8W)I<VES
M(&]F(&-A<&ET86QI<VTN($ET("!I<R!L87EI;F<-AT-=&AE(&=R;W5N9"!F;W(-AT-
M='5R;FEN9R!W:&%T($5L;&5N($UE:6MS:6YS(%=O;V0-AT-8V%L;',-AT-("=V87)I
M;W5S(&9R86=M96YT<R!O9B!O<'!O<VET:6]N)R!T;R`-AT-8V%P:71A;&ES;2!I
M;G1O(&-O;G-C:6]U<R!C;&%S<R!S=')U9V=L92X-AT-#0H-"-AT-T*,2!3964-AT-)T=L
M;V)A;&ES871I;VXZ(&$-AT-<F5D:79I<VEO;B!O9B!T:&4-AT-=V]R;&0-AT-8GD-AT-:6UP
M97)I86QI<VTG(&EN($9I9VAT(%)A8VES;2$-AT-1FEG:'0-AT-26UP97)I86QI<VTA
M(#$S,2!*=6YE+TIU;'D-AT-,3DY-BX-"C(-AT-5&AE<V4-AT-<&]S:71I;VYS(&%P<&5A
M<B!I;B`G0V%P:71A;&ES;2P-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;BP-AT-86YD(&5P;V-H86P-AT-
M<VAI9G1S.B!A;B!E>&-H86YG92<-AT-:6X-AT-36]N=&AL>2!2979I97<-AT-5F]L(#0X
M($YO(#D-AT-<'`Q.2TS,BX-AT-5&AA="!D:6%M971R:6-A;&QY(&]P<&]S960-AT-<&]S
M:71I;VYS(&]N('1H92!S:6=N:69I8V%N8V4-AT-;V8-AT-9VQO8F%L:7-A=&EO;B!A
M<F4-AT-:&5L9"!B>2!W<FET97)S('1H<F]U9VAO=70-AT-=&AE('!O;&ET:6-A;"!S
M<&5C=')U;2!F<F]M("=R:6=H="<-AT-=&\-AT-)VQE9G0G(&]N;'D-AT-861D<R!T;R!T
M:&4-AT-8V]N9G5S:6]N+B`-"C,-AT-5&AI<R!W87,-AT-82!F879O=7)A8FQE(')E=FEE
M=R!O9B!A(&)O;VL-AT-8GD-AT-4&%U;"!(:7)S="!A;F0-AT-1W)A:&%M92!4:&]M<'-O
M;B!';&]B86QI<V%T:6]N(&EN(%%U97-T:6]N(%!O;&ET>2!0<F5S<R`Q.3DV
M+B!-871E<FEA;"!F<F]M('1H:7,-AT-8F]O:R!I<R!U<V5D(&EN(&UY(&5A<FQI
M97(-AT-87)T:6-L92!O;B!G;&]B86QI<V%T:6]N+B!4:&5Y(&AO;&0-AT-82!S:6UI
M;&%R('!O<VET:6]N('1O('1H870-AT-;V8-AT-2'5T=&]N(&%B;W9E+"!A<F=U:6YG
M('1H870-AT-)VYA=&EO;B!S=&%T97,L("!A;F0-AT-9F]R;7,-AT-;V8-AT-(&EN=&5R;F%T
M:6]N86P-AT-<F5G=6QA=&EO;B!C<F5A=&5D(&%N9"!S=7-T86EN960-AT-8GD-AT-;F%T
M:6]N('-T871E<RP-AT-<W1I;&P-AT-:&%V92!A(&9U;F1A;65N=&%L(')O;&4-AT-:6X-AT-
M<')O=FED:6YG(&=O=F5R;F%N8V4-AT-;V8-AT-=&AE(&5C;VYO;7D-AT-*'`Q.#4I+B<-
M"C0-AT-475O=&5S(&9R;VT-AT-2'5T=&]N(&%R92!F<F]M(&AI<R!B;V]K(%1H92!3
M=&%T92!792=R92!);B!*;VYA=&AA;B!#87!E(#$Y.34N($9O<B!M>2!R979I
M97<-AT-;V8-AT-=&AI<R!B;V]K('-E92`G5&AE('!O;&ET:6-A;"!E8V]N;VUY(&]F
M('1H92!N97<-AT-;6ED9&QE(&-L87-S)R!I;B!&:6=H="!286-I<VTA($9I9VAT
M($EM<&5R:6%L:7-M(2`Q,C0-AT-07!R:6PO36%Y(#$Y.34N#0HU(%-E92!7;W)L
M9"!);G9E<W1M96YT(%)E<&]R="`H5TE2*2`-AT-54X-AT-,3DY-B!F;W(-AT-:6YF;W)M
M871I;VXN($]T:&5R(&9I9W5R97,-AT-87)E('1A:V5N(&9R;VT-AT-;7D-AT-96%R;&EE
M<B!A<G1I8VQE(&]R(&5A<FQI97(-AT-5TE2(')E<&]R=',N#0HV($9I9W5R97,-AT-
M9G)O;2!4:&4-AT-5V]R;&0-AT-1&5V96QO<&UE;G0-AT-4F5P;W)T($]54"`Q.3DV(&%N
M9"!4:&4-AT-2'5M86X-AT-1&5V96QO<&UE;G0-AT-4F5P;W)T("!/55`-AT-,3DY-BX-"C<-
'"-AT-T*#0H-"G5M
`
end


     --- from list marxism-general-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---

   

Driftline Main Page

 

Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005