Date: Wed, 30 Oct 1996 13:05:06 +1000 (EST) From: Gary MacLennan <g.maclennan-AT-qut.edu.au> Subject: Re: M-I: No more Mr Nice guy Per has described Adam's position as "silly". I tend to agree though honestly I am reluctant to use that word of someone I like and admire. But really to chuck the label "centrist" around at this political juncture is a bit of a giggle. This is soo.....o retro Bolshevik that one almost detects the postmodern tongue in the cheek. But Adam is too earnest a chap for that, surely (?). Now Louis P. is I believe chopping steadily into the Bolshevik party tradition as it has come down to us through Trotsky and Zinovief. I have been part of that tradition and everything he says rings true with me. the possibility that Louis might be correct is too horrible for the party people to contemplate. So he has to be attacked. I have written to Adam off list about my experiences with the ISO. I have talked a little about this on-list. Basically Armstrong and Co, including a treacherous little bastard named John Minns, crushed a group of us in 1981. It was not because we weren't revolutionaries. Nor was it because we did not have ISO politics. We represented a challenge to the leadership of Armstrong and Co. and so had to go. We were also victims of Cliff's turn to Leninism-Trotskyism. The fact that we did not realize we were a threat did not save us. Professional revolutionaries do not make mistakes when it comes to securing their own bureaucratic power. We were accused of being rightist when in reality we were fighting the sectist ultra-Bolshevik, splitting and wrecking politics that Armstrong flourishes in. Over time ISO went though a series of splits and eventually the line which we had pushed in 1981 was used to crush Armstrong. Words cannot convey my sense of the fitness of this. The hard man bumped off by another hard man. I cannot disclose Adam's comments on my post to him without his permission. But I will say that in his posts he refuses to acknowledge the political realities of someone like myself. There are thousands like me who have been spat out of the trotskyist organizations. Were we wrong or were the little groups wrong? Should we be dismissed as "centrists" so that those who give their lives to the little groups can sleep more comfortably? regards Gary --- from list marxism-international-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005