Date: Tue, 12 Nov 1996 13:55:58 -0800 (PST) From: Scott McLemee <mclemee-AT-igc.apc.org> Subject: Re: M-I: Cyberseminar Progress Report 1 On Tue, 12 Nov 1996, Jason A Schulman wrote: > I was under the impression that the Johnson-Forrest crew was something > less than uncritical regarding the immanence of revolution. > [Interesting citation from Hal Draper cut here] > > Perhaps Cde. McLemee can clear this up? > > -- Jason Thanks for the Draper citation, which I hadn't seen. While written with a poison pen, Draper's characterization is accurate enough -- the Johnsonites were indeed ultra-revolutionary, or at least highly optimistic about the possibility of revolution in the post-WW II period. (I'm not sure, but I think Lou P. has confused Johnson-Forest with the more sanguine Morrow-Goldman faction in the SWP, which at around the same time was developing a more critical perspective on what's been called "fatalistic Marxism"). Anyway, I don't want to start writing my paper just yet -- but let me say this much for now. Johnson-Forest offered a hell of a lot more than "soviets in the sky" (as Irving Howe, like Draper their polemical opponent, dubbed the Johnsonites' revolutionary enthusiasm). They never saw a copy of HISTORY AND CLASS CONSCIOUSNESS, but in many ways are rather like the Lukacs of that earlier, heady moment. The same strengths, the same weaknesses -- including an ultraleftism that cohabited with a powerful emphasis on the centrality of dialectics to Marxism. Finally: a note of thanks to all parties involved in convening this cyberseminar. I'm really glad to have a chance to discuss this stuff, which I've been researching for eight years. Anybody in DC who makes it to Vertigo Books this weekend -- when I'm giving a talk, "C.L.R. James and Richard Wright: A Conversation," in connection with the new book CLR JAMES ON THE "NEGRO QUESTION" -- please say hello. It would be great to associate a person with a sig-line . . . --- from list marxism-international-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005