Date: Tue, 09 Sep 1997 01:21:26 +0200
From: Hinrich Kuhls <kls-AT-unidui.uni-duisburg.de>
Subject: M-I: A pedant's argument - and his disgust [resent]


Playing on my weakness to express my views in the English language Louis
Godena refused to argue with the arguments of my last  post where I
criticized his 
superficial views of the historically unique event of the Holocaust and the
connection to his understanding of Marxism.

His reply:

"My point was, the deaths of four to six million Jews at the hands of one
sector of nationalist capital is hardly unique in the annals of human
history."
(Louis Godena at 19:45 06.09.97 -0400)

Pedant as I am I just ask for only one further answer: Do you also agree to
this following statement which has - disgustfully - yet not been rejected
by any of the list members:

"In fact it was the Jewish leaders in many of the ghettoes that "willing"
sent off their own people to the gas chambers!"
(Robert Malecki at 12:10 07.09.97 +0200)

I am still breathless reading such crap in a surrounding that takes up the
demand of a Marxist discourse. Such crap is beyond all humanity.

Disgustfully,

Hinrich Kuhls






     --- from list marxism-international-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---