Date: Mon, 6 Oct 1997 22:53:41 +0200
From: Hugh Rodwell <m-14970-AT-mailbox.swipnet.se>
Subject: Re: M-I: Attention Lou Proyect. Re Adolfo's flagrant provocations


Carrol writes:

>	Please ignore Adolfo as we have mostly come to ignore
>Malecki. With his last few posts Adolfo has more or less clearly
>declared his objective solidarity with the likes of Malecki as
>a provacateur and wrecker.

Just for the record and any newcomers -- Bob Malecki is not a provocateur
or wrecker of lists, but he does a damn good job of provoking Menshevik and
Stalinist know-alls like Proyect & Adolfo by challenging their smug
complacency and wrecking their pretensions to list and left hegemony and
consensus.

Carrol still pretends Louis P is worthy of a place in Marxist debate. He
has learnt nothing from Louis's desperate attempts to smear Bob M as a cop
and his crushing failure to deliver.

Carrol also chooses to ignore Louis P's documented contacts with
subscribers' employers to inform them of their activities in connection
with the list.

Not to mention the reptilean malevolence with which he flings personal
slander against his political opponents.

Louis's the provocateur and wrecker. "Malecki" is his main scapegoat.

Cheers,

Hugh

PS Louis's potted reviews, compilations and summaries are just a price he
willingly pays so he can get to attack and block as best he can the real
revolutionary tendencies on the list.




     --- from list marxism-international-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---