Date: Sun, 12 Jan 1997 12:28:45 -0500 (EST) From: Gerald Levy <glevy-AT-pratt.edu> Subject: M-TH: Re: Louis N Proyent - snitch Russ Pearson wrote: > I've yet to come up with a mail on why Fred Jameson is worth reading, but > this dribble over whether someone said this or that is certainly not. If I > wanted to engage with this sort of stuff I'd don my 'ultra-left pit bull' > outfit and do it elsewhere. Out of respect for Jukka, I was ready to let this thread die (to be taken up later on m-int or another forum). Anyway, I will briefly respond to your comments by explaining why the issues _are_ important (and worth reading). (1) A person claiming to be a "marxist" has engaged in vile anti-labor actions, both by publicly threatening to contact the employers of listmembers and in at least one instance actually attempting to get that person disciplined by management. (2) That person claims that the above threats and actions were "jokes" but that simply does not tally with the facts, i.e. _his own statements_ on record in the m-int archives. (3) When the moderators of m-int were informed of the above, they chose not to seriously investigate those charges. Why? Because the person in question (Louis N. Proyent) is a personal friend of theirs. Others, like the vulgar empiricist D. Henwood, have also attempted to make excuses for Proyent out of personal allegiance to him. (4) Rather than punishing the culprit (Proyent), the moderators of m-int (the three stooges) punished the person bringing the charges against Proyent by suspending his ability to post to m-int for 2 weeks. What was the reason given? The spokesperson for the three Proyent stooges said that it was because of comments that this person said about m-int on m-thaxis. This action by the moderators of m-int was not only in violation of m-int rules (that they themselves drafted), but also sets a chilling precedent for Spoons lists -- that being that if a person of one list (m-thaxis) makes critical comments about another list (m-int) on another list (m-thaxis), then the person can be suspended from posting to their list (m-int). So much for freedom of speech on the Internet! So much for the pretentious claims by the m-int moderators that they are opposed to censorship! So much for principles! Jerry --- from list marxism-thaxis-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005