Date: Sun, 12 Feb 95 19:31:58 GMT From: Chris Burford <cburford-AT-gn.apc.org> Subject: Re: Crisis Hello Will, It is good to have more people contribute from this corner of the planet. I happen to agree very much with your overall statement. Then it occurred to me that we tend to assume most arguments take place in the USA. This maybe deprives us of the stimulation to make more of a contribution from this island (though now that I am getting into the archives, it seems wpc has been making a contribution from the Red Clyde from the beginning of the list) >>it is easy to see evidence of crisis... mass unemployment,financial dislocation, beggars on the streets. But such evidence of crisis has been easy to find in much of capitalism's history.<< Surely. The crises are a cyclical self-regenerating biological process. The fact that people are unemployed is already evidence that a portion of old capital has been destroyed and a new cycle of increased capitalist activity can start again. The unemployed are like the fallen debris on the floor of the rain forest lying around as nutrients for capital accumulation to occur again. (What I am not so sure about is why there is usually a long period of stagnation before the period of superheating - except for a minority of countries in the global economy, which seem to have got into a virtuous circle). Yes the evidence that Scott Marshall so graphically gave from his neighbour hood shows him to be a good agitator and a populist, but I am not sure whether he consciously has been telling the wretched of Chicago that it really is the final crisis. There is 50% unemployment among the young black males where I live, and I could not give that message, even if I had the setting to do so. I agree with you Will, therefore that >A better question is whether there have been any recent developments that threaten the fundamental stability of the sytem.< Chaos theory can model how a stable cycling system can become unstable under certain intensities of input. The most relevant analogy comes not from the weather but from Verhulst's equation about the mathematics of population growth. Capitalist economic cycles behave like a species bumping up repeatedly against an upper limit on its expansion. That upper limit I suggest is most plausibly "The total labour-power of society, which is embodied in the sum total of the values of all commodities produced by that society" (Capital Chapter 1, about page 5 in any edition). It is out of this pool of value that old capital and new alike have to claw surplus value and there has to be enough purchasing power to consume the mass of commodities. Its like a species of fish reproducing in a lake. DISAGREEMENTS Perhaps you may disagree with some of the above. About your specific suggestions I think they are good but we need to get into them more if they are to be really valuable. >1) The globalisation of the world economy undermining the nation state< Very important that we think global, but the undermining of the nation state is wanted by the transnationals. It only causes political problems. eg repeatedly now in the process of European integration. I suggest the turbulence really comes from the uneven accumulation of capital within regions as well as the world, so that migration and racism is rising. >2) The collapse of the communist block creating an integrated world market and thus a world proletariat< This needs a lot of expansion. In systems theory it was predictable that with the loss of its foil and alibi, in the evil empire, capitalism would soon look a victor increasingly dismayed by its own contradictions. It has rather slipped on a banana skin at the finishing post. But wasn't there already very substantially an integrated world market and world proletariat prior to the collapse of the communist block? What is on your mind? >3) The impossibility of major imperialist war because of the scale of weapons of mass destruction< Why is this a factor for INstability? >4) The development of communication resources allowing workers to network on a non-hierarchical yet international basis< In terms of economic resistance to the encroachments of the transnationals, this has hardly started and is not causing turbulence for capitalism, let me suggest. Are you suggesting politically that in the era of Internet, an organisational system like a Leninist democratic centralist party is unnecessary and likely to be outmanouevred, whereas guidance and direction to the populist concerns of the day could be provided by a *network* of marxists in every country? But would Jon be up to the job of moderator? and what are the signs that Internet has caused instability in the world capitalist system yet? On the contrary three trillion dollars flows round the computer terminals each day very smoothly, with only the occasional Black Monday. I would suggest by contrast that although the speed of communications and of developing technological change, is accelerating and is highly likely to cause much greater instability to a world system like capitalism in the future, at the moment the main phenomenon is that there has been something of a phase shift, a shift of set point, of the levels of unemployment in the advanced western capitalist countries. This has been described by Ormerod and was illustrated by the international summit last year on employment. There are some indications that this is a secular and not a cyclical shift. It is unstable not domestically, (eg the Conservative government of the 1930's in Britain was not imperilled at all but high unemployment), but because of the indication that the advanced western capitalist countries have been wounded in the competition with rising Asian capitalist economies and do not know how to operate on full capacity without the risk of inflation. Anyway that is me sticking my neck out. It is nice to hear from you Will. It was a stimulating post. I look forward to some constructive disagreements back from you. Failing that Best Wishes in return anyway! Chris Burford Community Psychiatrist, specialising in schizophrenia. Member of the Forum for Marxism, Philosophy and Science, and the Southern Africa Economic Research Unit, SAERU. London "Only connect..." --- from list marxism-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu --- ------------------
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005