Date: Tue, 7 Feb 1995 10:34:15 -0500 From: Howie Chodos <howie-AT-magi.com> Subject: Re: Consciousness lags Louis Proyect wrote: >Since the lag between objective conditions and revolutionary >consciousness has marked almost the entire twentieth century, does this >explain the allure of Gramsci, Althusser and the Frankfurt school? I'm >not trying to pick a fight with anybody, just asking.... It seems to me that he touches on some absolutely fundamental questions here. If there is a "lag" between objective conditions and revolutionary consciousness, can we ever be sure that this lag will be made up? I would argue that we cannot, that there is not, in other words, any guarantee that any specific set of objective conditions has to produce any specific response in a given set of people. If this is right then we need to ask ourselvers what we mean by revolutionary consciousness. Consciousness of what? Is there a single body of thought, feeling, political positions, or whatever that we can refer to as embracing class consciousness, that exists "out there" somewhere, that is waiting to be discovered? This is why I find the "lag" metaphor a bit misleading. It implies that there is such a consciousness, and that the problem is that the agents of change have yet to become aware of what their consciousness should be. This is a tough problem, since, at the same time we don't want to lose our ability to criticise existing social relations on the grounds that "it's all a matter of opinion". This would seem to suggest that we need to find away to hold on to two seemingly contradictory propositions at the same time. First, that it is possible to argue that capitalism is objectively bad. Second, that this does not mean that there is a single solution, a single path to socialism, a single party to lead us there, a single set of policy proposals that needs to be advocated, etc. The question is how to do this. I think this may also touch on some previous postings on "Marxism and Philosophy". I am new to this, so if I have covered old ground, forgive (and enlighten) me. Howie Chodos ------------------
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005