Date: Wed, 2 Aug 1995 09:36:36 -0400 (EDT) From: Louis N Proyect <lnp3-AT-columbia.edu> Subject: Bosnia Louis Proyect: U.S. policy on Bosnia-Herzegovina is being driven--as our Somalia policy was--by pictures. Senator Diane Feinstein, Democrat of California, was quoted on the front page of Friday's New York Times saying that she'd switched her position on ending the arms embargo of Bosnia because "one image punched through to me: that young woman hanging from a tree. That to me said it all. (This amounted to a near subliminal plug for the power of the Times, which had run the photo 13 days before.) Journalists, too, have been inspired by that gruesome image. A description of the photo led off last week's Village Voice article on Bosnia and provided a starting point for Ed Koch's July 28 New York Post column. The problem with policy or analysis by photo is that every picture tells too many stories. Looking at one photo, Koch immediately found himself seeing another, surefire image: "A United Nations onlooker said that what he saw in Srebenica reminded him of the photograph of the little Jewish boy in the Warsaw Ghetto surrounded by Nazi troops." The fact that, on the very day Koch's column appeared, Croatian troops retook Bosanko Grahovo and Glamoc reminds us that this is a civil war, making the Serb-Nazi equation simplistic. Even if you accept the premise for the length of a Post column, Koch's desperate search for some hero to redeem the West's failing of Jews in the '30s led him to some truly astounding positions. "It is incredible that 22 Muslim/Arab nations and over a dozen non-Arab nations--like Indonesia, Iran, Pakistan and Turkey--can stand by and allow their co- religionists to be destroyed," howled Koch. "It is unconscionable that they have failed to rush to their side with men and arms." Koch's anger has blinded him to the fact that, as CNN, CBS, and others reported last week, Muslim nations have been covertly supplying the Bosnian government with arms and material for nearly a year. (Indeed, a Washington Post front-pager on Friday noted that British and French officials have accused the Clinton administration of sponsoring such airlifts, a charge the president curtly denied.) More importantly, could Koch have given a minute's thought to what it means to encourage Muslim nations like Iraq, nuclear-equipped Pakistan, or the butchers of Indonesia to begin an activist foreign policy in places where they perceive Muslims to be wronged? This sounds like a formula for a full-scale Middle East war, in which Koch's beloved Israel would be a prime target. If Ed Koch were a lone chowderhead on this issue, his hysteria would hardly be worth attacking. Alas, virtually the entire U.S. press corps last week underplayed the probable effects of ending the embargo, acting as if a Senate vote would somehow prevent the flood of horrible photos. I cannot recall the last time I agreed with something Charles Krauthammer had written, but he was surely correct when he predicted in Friday's Washington Post that "those who smugly think that after Srebenica and Zepa hell had already broken loose will be surprised at the yet untapped reserves of Balkan ferocity as the French and British go home and the Serbs press their military advantage before it disappears." The American media have uncritically accepted the Republican- inspired idea that unilaterally lifting the arms embargo will force the weapons to go where we want them to go. Since the White House is opposed to the Senate bill as passed, it is impossible that any sanctioned arms shipments are going to happen before October at the earliest. With UN troops scrambling to get out, and with the fierce Bosnian winter underway, how will Bob Dole insure that the already disadvantaged Bosnian army doesn't end up losing arms to the Serbs? This scenario has been boldly predicted by General Ratko Mladic, the Bosnian Serb army commander, who was quoted in the July 28 Financial Times saying that "the lifting of the arms embargo would suit me because all the supply routes could easily come under my control." This complicating perspective has eluded the U.S. press. (From Press Clips, a column by James Ledbetter that appears in the current issue (8/8/95) of the Village Voice, a liberal NYC weekly) --- from list marxism-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu --- ------------------
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005