From: MLuftmensch-AT-hubcap.mlnet.com (Michael Luftmensch) Subject: re-border controls Date: 12 Feb 1996 06:54:50 GMT re-border controls luftmensch: Rakesh Bhandari's suggestions for the discussion of border controls (in a post on Feb. 4) were most welcome! He wrote of the need to examine these matters with the help of a theory of uneven development. I'm not familiar with many of the books he mentioned, but clearly, discussion of borders and migration leads into this territory. To what extent, he asked, is the argument that the globalization of capital will help to lessen illegal immigration by creating employment opportunities abroad true? I would answer: Not at all. Unemployment is rising around the world. According to the International Labour Organization, 30 per cent of the world's labour force is unemployed or underemployed. For the peoples of Africa, Latin America and much of Asia, the current crisis is by far worse than anything experienced in Europe and North America during the thirties. With every passing decade, more and more people are becoming superfluous to the market system. In an article in The Nation (Nov. 13, 1995) David Bacon quoted Juan Jose Delagado of the Democratic Revolutionary Party to the effect that the Mexican government is legalizing slavery with a wage equivalent of (US)$2.50 a day. Bacon concludes that US economic and trade policies are pushing Mexicans to immigrate, but US immigration policy punishes them when they do. In this regard, the US is hardly unique. The onslaught against migrants is growing more intense with each passing year. England, France, Italy and Germany have all recently introduced legislation that would further erode the human rights of migrants and tighten immigration restrictions on would-be immigrants. In the case of Germany, this is particularly ironic. It wasn't that long ago that the people of Eastern Europe rebelled - with the Federal Republic's enthusiastic support - against the restrictions placed on their freedom of movement by the Communist regimes. Today, a cordon sanitaire is being erected to prevent them from exercising that same freedom. When EC ministers met in Spain to hammer out a joint immigration policy a few months ago, thousands of people protested in Barcelona against the "Wall of Shame" that is being erected around Fortress Europe. Discrimination is being written into the fabric of the EC. In each member country, there will now be two kinds of foreigners with two very different sets of rights. Popular perceptions of otherness are being mediated by the state. This is very much part of the new European racism. Similar movements are afoot in the United States. I agree wholeheartedly with Carlos in his response to Kevin Cobral's distinction between "legal" and "illegal" immigrants. Jon Flanders wrote that the only pro-working class position on immigration controls is to oppose them and support full citizenship and labor rights for immigrants. "Illegal and legal is one of the worst divisions within the working class... Who is here legally (in the USA) anyway?" Brian Carnell responded with the following statement: "Wow...will you even let them make a profit off their labor???" Undocumented workers suffer horrendous exploitation precisely because of their precarious legal status. Any resistance can be nipped in the bud by calling in the immigration authorities. Moreover, the existence of the controls in force on the US-Mexican border not only criminalize migrants from the south, they are also instrumental in exploiting Mexican workers, particularly those working in the maquiladora industry - the assembly plants that employ aprox. one fifth of the Mexican work force. luftmensch --- from list marxism-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu --- ------------------
Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005