Date: Wed, 3 Jul 1996 19:37:21 +0200 (MET DST)
From: malecki-AT-algonet.se (Robert Malecki)
Subject: Re: Vanguards?



>Louis: Robert, I am not foaming at all. I am simply making the
>observation, which is borne out your own memoirs, that you are not
>involved in political action. That's OK. Neither is most of humanity. What
>the rest of humanity doesn't do, however, is preach to a Marxism mailing
>list about the need to go out and build revolutionary parties.

Oh yes you were and now you are lying. My book has to do with the Vietnam 
war and the situation i found myself in at the time..

You and i both know that I have worked in organisations including some 
sister parties to the SWP in America for many years. But also in and with 
the Spartacist for quite a number of years. But you are trying to openly lie 
about this stuff time and again.

In fact while the left and the Tudah party were supporting the Mullahs we 
were trying to desperately warn them of the danger. Ask Zeynep about the 
exiles in Turkey what a bloodbath it caused for them.

In fact while you were sending engineers to Nicaragua we were talking 
politics and why the Sandinistas were incapable of going all the way.

In fact while the left was cheering the Polish Solidarnosc and the Chatholic 
church we were fighting for proletarian independence and a political revolution.

In all of these examples the left proved themselves as both incorrect and in 
some cases literally a blood bath of their own members like in Iran.

So don,t tell me that you haven,t heard this before on this list. Because 
you are a liar and a synical coward whining about malecki,s being a lumpen 
piece of shit.

I got more Bolshevik politics on one thumb then in your whole body Louis. 
The only thing you have got is access to a library and a good education in 
order to poduce a lot of Menshevik bullshit on this list..

In fact, it enrages you Louis because I have got your number. Unlike you I 
do not look at my experience in the USec as something that destroyed my poor 
little ego like you. But as a part of my development towards Bolshevik 
Leninist politics. You have taken another road to the right politically and 
filled with bitter hatred for Trotskyists in general because of your own 
experiences in the SWP.

A tired and defeated old man. A liar and just a right wing Menshevik on the 
party question at best..

Well, you can continue with your political trajectory to the right and away 
>from Bolshevik politics. Good luck. However there are people who will oppose 
you time and again.

Warm Regards
malecki




     --- from list marxism-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---