Date: Mon, 16 Sep 96 23:13:02 PDT
From: PO <global-AT-uk.pi.net>
Subject: Re: On Iraq 



* We had a very interesting debate with comrade Bob Malecki on Iraq. It is a 
good debate and have nothing in common of some low quality insults-exchanges 
that we could see on the internet.

Bob said:
"What is your position. Drive the Jews into the sea? Or what? Otherwise you 
have my criticism of the part on the Israeli question either you support it 
or you are against it."

Jose answer:
No, Bob WE ARE AGAINST EXPELLING THE JEWS IN TO SEA.
That was the position of Nahuel Moreno. We are in favour of the unity of the 
Israeli Jew working class with the Arab workers. We are in favour of a 
socialist federation in the middle east in which the different ethnic groups 

of the Israelian Jews (ashkenazis, Falashas, sefardites, etc.) should have 
the right to exist freely. 
We don't put an equal sign between the Zionist nationalism and the 
Palestinean nationalism. We don't put an equal sign between the White KKK 
nationalism in the US with the Black militants nationalism. Despite our 
disagreements with malcolm X and the Black panthers we would defend them 
against the White Power nationalists. We have the same attitude in 
Palestine.
We don't agree with Hamas and FDPLP bombs on israeli kids and civilians. 
Nevertheless we defend every palestinian anti-zionist fighter against 
repression. We advocate a class policy: the only way in which the Arab 
workers could smash the Zionist state is not in alliance with their own 
bourgeoisie, it is in alliance with the Israeli Jew workers. 

I honestly think that you are wrong in renouncing the support to a document 
which you help to draft. Despite our differences we want to express with you 

our solidarity against with-hunts in the internet.  





     --- from list marxism-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---