File spoon-archives/nietzsche.archive/nietzsche_2000/nietzsche.0007, message 31


Date: Wed, 19 Jul 2000 10:23:15 -0700 (PDT)
Subject: Re: Freddy My Love


I don't know if I would be able to deal with 'love' If
I held the future of mankind in my hand as Nietzsche
believed he did. As he has stated often enough, his
journey was lonely, over icy mountain tops, through
deserts, etc. To take mankind and the universe as your
object without the mediation of a lover, as most
mortals do, requires concentration and harshness. This
does not mean that Nietzsche was incapable of loving
or that no one qualified. His object of love on that
morning in early January was - a horse.

Rutger.
--- "Chand B. Rangwani" <orpheus-AT-india.crosswinds.net>
wrote:
> 
> Have been wondering about old Freddy's attitude
> towards love. I know he would have liked to be in
> love, because he wrote lyrically of ice cream in his
> letters! And he loved the love poesy of Rilke and
> Hoelderin so much.
> 
> I think he had a simplistic notion which saw eros,
> agape and philia as the same. For Zarathustra I
> think love was inculcating self-improvement in the
> other. "For what does he know of love who has not
> been obliged to despise just what he loved." 
> 
> This is quite the same as the early aesthetic
> Kierkegaard for whom the purpose of love was to make
> the other more interesting, more like oneself, more
> for oneself, because as K said, he was too
> intelligent, too existentially bored (anomie) by the
> common love of women. 
> 
> In this I feel, both were short-sighted. In their
> lives, both would react to a person's shortcomings
> and walk away instead of accepting them as equals
> and then working towards mutual support. To free
> oneself from chains is one thing, but to free
> oneself from freedom is quite another! Nz warned us
> about the vanity of the liberated, but I think he
> succumbed to the same in his own life. No one was
> good enough!
>  
> The basic premise of eros is to start with the
> notion that the other is equal, worthy. Romanticism
> worked in the 12th c because the socially oppressed
> women were treated as equals by their lovers. But
> look at Freddy. He writes: "You have not the
> remotest conception of what it means to be closely
> related to the man and to the destiny in whom the
> question of millenia has been decided -  I hold,
> quite literally, the future of mankind in my hand."
> 
> Love entails the strength to accept and then love
> something which is not part of us and can probably
> never be. Like de Beauvoir puts it: "It is only as
> something strange, forbidden, as something free,
> that the other is revealed as an other. And to love
> him genuinely is to love him in his otherness and in
> that freedom by which he escapes. empathy at its
> best preserves, yet seeks to know the `strangeness',
> respects the boundary between self and the other
> that the `forbiddenness affirms, does not seek to
> assimilate or obliterate the freedom."
> 
> On that count, which sounds pretty good to me, I
> think the entire edifice of Nz's thought would
> collapse. For what would loving oneself - truly,
> deeply (and not egoistically as Nz'eans are wont to
> do) imply then? That if you have Nz'ean strength,
> you would love everyone, apply Nz's perspectivism to
> other people's way of living. So why do Nz and his
> disciples always seem so full of hatred, of
> judgmentality? And could anyone clarify (with a
> little creativity) how a typical Nietzschean romance
> would go!
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 	--- from list nietzsche-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu
> ---
> 


====APROPOS - Rutger H Cornets de Groot, Writer, Translator
English-Dutch Freelance Translation Services
Essays on Film, Culture, Art, Literature, Philosophy
a p r o p o s
http://sites.netscape.net/cornets/apropos
apropos-AT-eznet.net / cornets-AT-yahoo.com
"The quality of a good translation can never be captured by the original".

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get Yahoo! Mail  Free email you can access from anywhere!
http://mail.yahoo.com/


	--- from list nietzsche-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu ---


   

Driftline Main Page

 

Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005