File spoon-archives/seminar-11.archive/benjamin_1999/seminar-11.9910, message 16


From: "Warren Goldstein" <wgoldstein-AT-stlawu.edu>
Subject: Re: starting the discussion
Date: Fri, 15 Oct 1999 07:16:05 -0400


This is a multi-part message in MIME format.


Dear Benjamin list,

Sorry for being a little behind in this discussion and for deviating from the last thread on the division of labor.  I have been saving these threads and have finally had the chance to read them.

Some of you I know from the frankfurt-school list and the conference in Amsterdam.  But, for others, let me introduce myself. 

My dissertation at the New School for Social Research was entitled "Messianism and Marxism: Walter Benjamin and Ernst Bloch's Dialectical Theories of Secularization."  In the dissertation I attempt to explain Benjamin's mixture of Messianism and Marxism through a dialectical conception of secularization.  Benjamin has dialectical theories of secularization in his theory of allegory, theory of collective dreaming and awakening, profane illumination and decline of aura. I think the the piece that best illustrates Benjamin's dialectical conception of secularization is the political-theological fragment in which the messianic and profane move simulatenously in opposite directions.

Since I have finished the dissertation, I have found myself at a challenge of trying to defend my work to American mainstream sociologists.  Perhaps this is a waste of time but having done the dissertation in sociology in the United States, I find myself with no other choice.  I am currently working in an essay entitled "Walter Benjamin: A Sociologist?" in book being edited by Mary Ann Romano entitled Lost Sociologists Reconsidered (Edwin Mellen Press).  I too am reading Keith Tester's book in an attempt to further develop the argument about his relevance for urban sociology.  Most of my research lately has been on the debate within sociology of religion over the theory of secularization.  I am attempting to use Benjamin and Bloch's connection to Weber and Marx to further develop a dialectical conception of secularization to be used against more mainstream arguments prevalent within sociology of religion.

I do look forward to being part of the list.

Sincerely,

Warren S. Goldstein
Visiting Assistant Professor
Department of Sociology
St. Lawrence University
Canton, NY  13617
voice: (315) 229-5201
fax: (315) 229- 5803
e-mail: wgoldstein-AT-stlawu.edu

P.S. Does anybody know how I can get that issue of Critical Inquiry?

HTML VERSION:

Dear Benjamin list,
 
Sorry for being a little behind in this discussion and for deviating from the last thread on the division of labor.  I have been saving these threads and have finally had the chance to read them.
 
Some of you I know from the frankfurt-school list and the conference in Amsterdam.  But, for others, let me introduce myself. 
 
My dissertation at the New School for Social Research was entitled "Messianism and Marxism: Walter Benjamin and Ernst Bloch's Dialectical Theories of Secularization."  In the dissertation I attempt to explain Benjamin's mixture of Messianism and Marxism through a dialectical conception of secularization.  Benjamin has dialectical theories of secularization in his theory of allegory, theory of collective dreaming and awakening, profane illumination and decline of aura. I think the the piece that best illustrates Benjamin's dialectical conception of secularization is the political-theological fragment in which the messianic and profane move simulatenously in opposite directions.
 
Since I have finished the dissertation, I have found myself at a challenge of trying to defend my work to American mainstream sociologists.  Perhaps this is a waste of time but having done the dissertation in sociology in the United States, I find myself with no other choice.  I am currently working in an essay entitled "Walter Benjamin: A Sociologist?" in book being edited by Mary Ann Romano entitled Lost Sociologists Reconsidered (Edwin Mellen Press).  I too am reading Keith Tester's book in an attempt to further develop the argument about his relevance for urban sociology.  Most of my research lately has been on the debate within sociology of religion over the theory of secularization.  I am attempting to use Benjamin and Bloch's connection to Weber and Marx to further develop a dialectical conception of secularization to be used against more mainstream arguments prevalent within sociology of religion.
 
I do look forward to being part of the list.
 
Sincerely,
 
Warren S. Goldstein
Visiting Assistant Professor
Department of Sociology
St. Lawrence University
Canton, NY  13617
voice: (315) 229-5201
fax: (315) 229- 5803
e-mail: wgoldstein-AT-stlawu.edu
 
P.S. Does anybody know how I can get that issue of Critical Inquiry?
-------- from list seminar-11-AT-lists.village.virginia.edu -------

Driftline Main Page

 

Display software: ArchTracker © Malgosia Askanas, 2000-2005